Basford & Offermann 2012, "Beyond Leadership: the Impact of Coworker Relationships on Employee Motivation and Intent to Stay"

In: Business and Management

Submitted By vizzaa
Words 2309
Pages 10
A critical review of Basford & Offermann 2012, "Beyond leadership: The impact of coworker relationships on employee motivation and intent to stay", Journal of Management and Organization, vol. 18, no. 6, pp. 807-817.

Relationships between coworkers have a great influence in people’s lives. While the importance of interpersonal relationships is widely supported by psychological literature, the specific impact of relationships between coworkers has been carried out by too few studies. The present study of Basford & Offermann (2012) was aimed to put an addition to the small but growing interest of researchers on coworker relations. Basford & Offermann (2012) conducted the research to study whether positive employees outcomes may derive from good peer relationship, while negative outcomes obtain from poor coworker relationships. The major aim of this research was to investigate the impact of coworker relationships on the two specific outcomes - employee motivation and intent to stay.

In this article, it was comprised of two main parts. First, the examination of whether the relationships of coworkers could, beyond supervisor and senior manager support, become a unique influence on other employees’ motivation and intent to stay. Three relationships, namely supervisory versus coworker relationships, importance of coworker relationships and concurrent examination of coworker and supervisory relationships were taken into examination. Second, the test of the generalization of these findings was conducted in order to explore whether employee job status moderates these relationships.

In the first main part of the article, Basford & Offermann raise three relationships to examine a unique impact on coworker motivation and retention. The first issue, the authors clarified that relationships between supervisors and employees are quite different…...

Similar Documents

Effective Leadership in Organizations and Its Impact on Employee Satisfaction

...Abstract The purpose of this research is to discover ways for effective leadership and the impact it has on employee satisfaction. Leadership, management and supervision are terms which mean the same but are used similarly. A leader/manager/supervisor is a person who sees something that needs to be done, and knows that they can help make it happen. A leader, manager, or supervisor sees opportunity and captures it. He/she sees future that can be different and better and help others see that picture too. He/she is a coach, an encourager and is willing to take risks today for something better for tomorrow. A leader/manager/supervisor is a communicator, coordinator and listener. There are several types of leadership styles and they will be discussed in this paper. Additionally, this paper will discuss case studies to deliberate the role of leadership between employees using the different leadership styles. The results of the findings showed effective leadership does have an impact on employee satisfaction. The main recommendations are for leaders to practice the “Golden Rule”. Introduction Leadership is a process influence between leaders and employees where the leader attempts to inspire the workers to achieve organizational goals. Leadership plays an important role to ensure the achievement of desired outcomes in both formal and informal groups. Effective leadership and employee satisfaction are two terms that are equally important. A......

Words: 3398 - Pages: 14

Employee Motivation and Performance

...[pic] Master of Business Administration (MBA) An analysis of the Effects of Rewards and Compensation on Employees’ Motivation and Performance Dissertation submitted in fulfillment of the requirements to the University of Wales for the award of the Degree Of Master of Business Administration (MBA) April 2012 DECLARATION This work has not previously been accepted in substance for any degree and is not being concurrently submitted in candidature for any degree. |Signed | |(Candidate) | |Date | | | STATEMENT 1 This thesis is the result of my own investigations, except where otherwise stated. The correction services have been used, the extent and nature of the correction is clearly marked in a footnote(s). Other sources are acknowledged by footnotes giving explicit references. A bibliography is appended. |Signed | |(Candidate) | |Date | | | STATEMENT 2 I hereby give consent for my thesis, if accepted, to be available for photocopying and for inter-library loan, and for the title and summary to be made available to outside......

Words: 17870 - Pages: 72

Employee Satisfaction Through Motivation

...Anna Salanova Sanni Kirmanen EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION AND WORK MOTIVATION Research in Prisma Mikkeli Bachelor’s Thesis Business Management March 2010 DESCRIPTION Date of the bachelor's thesis 15 March 2010 Author(s) Degree programme and option Anna Salanova, Sanni Kirmanen Name of the bachelor's thesis Business Management Employee Satisfaction and Work Motivation – Research in Prisma Mikkeli Abstract Human Resource Management is getting more important in the business nowadays, because people and their knowledge are the most important aspects affecting the productivity of the company. One of the main aspects of Human Resource Management is the measurement of employee satisfaction. Companies have to make sure that employee satisfaction is high among the workers, which is a precondition for increasing productivity, responsiveness, quality, and customer service. The aim of this thesis is to analyze the level of employee satisfaction and work motivation in Supermarket Prisma in Mikkeli. It also deals with the effect the culture has on employee satisfaction. The theoretical framework of this thesis includes such concepts as leadership, job satisfaction, motivation, rewards and cultural differences. The empirical part of the thesis and the questionnaire were created according to the mentioned concepts. The questionnaire also included parts where the questions about expectations of the employee, work environment and job organization were asked.......

Words: 27414 - Pages: 110

Employee Turnover and Motivation

...them. Employee turnover costs businesses owners both in time and productivity, and the impact is especially large at a small firm because of the relative connection to its size. But how can a small firm offer the right motivational factors to ensure that the staff remains within the organization? How can they compete with motivational employee benefits of larger corporations? This paper looks at one case company, a small accountancy firm located in Sweden that offers a wide range of financial services, mainly within four main categories: economic consultations, tax-returns, bookkeeping and auditing. The firm currently has 13 employees of different educational background, divided into two sections; bookkeeping and auditing. The firm has one manager who is also the sole owner of the company. This person is an authorized accountant who will remain anonymous in this paper but referred to as “Laura” in the remaining of this paper. The firm is currently expanding but is experiencing difficulties in motivating well-educated employees to stay long term. During the past year, two employees have quit their jobs and one of the replacers is currently on sick leave due to burnout. The concern is that if the firm does not improve its employee retention, they will spend an excessive amount of time trying to recruit and train new people, so retention of the current employees is important. They want to look into this issue and provide a plan to improve retention. Purpose The intent of......

Words: 7668 - Pages: 31

The Relationship Between Employee Motivation and Job Involvement

...(2010) No 3 237 The relaTionship beTween employee moTivaTion and job involvemenT S Govender and SB Parumasur School of Management Studies, University of KwaZulu-Natal Accepted March 2010 Abstract The study aims to assess the current level of, and relationship between, employee motivation and job involvement among permanent and temporary employees in various departments in a financial institution. This cross-sectional study was undertaken on 145 employees who were drawn by using a simple random sampling technique. Data were collected using the Employee Motivation Questionnaire (Fourie, 1989) and the Job Involvement Questionnaire (Lodahl & Kejner, 1965) and, was analysed using descriptive and inferential statistics. The results indicate that there are significant intercorrelations among the majority of dimensions and sub-dimensions of employee motivation and job involvement. Recommendations are presented to provide practitioners and managers with guidelines for enhancing employee motivation and job involvement respectively. JEL J28, M12 1 Introduction Motivating staff may be a critical factor in ensuring that an organisation thrives and succeeds in an increasingly competitive environment. The rationale is that, as employees become increasingly motivated to perform in their jobs, the likelihood of their becoming job involved increases significantly. Hence, the researchers postulate the existence of a direct relationship between motivation and job involvement.......

Words: 9210 - Pages: 37

Impact of Reward System on Employee Motivation

...Group assignment MGT CENTRE FOR POSTGRADUATE STUDIES THE IMPACT OF REWARD SYSTEM ON EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION A QUANTITAVE STUDY OF GLOBAL COMPANIES      Programme Code & Name: Session: Subject Code & Name: Assignment Title: Student’s Names & ID: o Nguyen Vu Minh An o Li Jia o Dai Hairong o Hue Shin Yen o Zhangshan o Daiwei    Class Section: Lecturer: Submission Date: I13003385 I12002184 I12002129 I13003254 I12002130 I12002099 5A1 Ms. Yalini Easvaralingam 12th Aug, 2013 MBADI–Master of Business Administration May 2013 MGT6208 – Statistic and Decision Analysis Group Assignment 1 Group assignment MGT Table of Contents ABSTRACT ......................................................................................................................... 3 CHAPTER 1: INDTRODUCTION ....................................................................................... 3 1.1 Problem statement ........................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Research Objectives ........................................................................................................ 5 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW ............................................................................... 5 2.1 Employee motivation ...................................................................................................... 5 2.2 Reward management system ..................................................................................

Words: 7225 - Pages: 29

Employee Motivation and Organisational Performance

...Executive Summary This report discusses and examines employee motivation in an IT organisation. The report examines the benefits of employee motivation followed by the various theories concerning motivation. The initial portion of the report focuses on the benefits of employee motivation which is followed by a discussion of motivation theories – content theories and process theories. The report further tries to outline the various options or methods followed by organisations to drive higher levels of motivation among the workforce. The methods included in the report addresses the various rewards and recognition options, use of scorecards, fun and recreational activities, communication channels, learning and growth opportunities and corporate social responsibility as methods to effectively drive employee motivation levels. The report recommends the establishment of a basic framework with respect to hygiene factors of a workplace in order to successfully drive initiatives to motivate workforce. Further, the report concludes on the note that various other factors including cultural, political, social and spiritual needs should be considered while arriving at a combination of methods to drive higher levels of motivation. Success of the initiative would depend upon the appropriateness of technique and timeliness beyond other factors. Table of Contents Executive Summary ..........................................................................................

Words: 2957 - Pages: 12

Employee Motivation

...members. Recommendations indicate solution for the issues identified during the Innovation Audit and the Benchmarking exercise carried out. The leadership and the management roles of the company are critically analyzed and discussed under Task 04 on Recommendations. The total incremental costs that the company has to incur when implementing the recommendations are highlighted in the report and a budget estimate is drafted for implementing the recommendations. Task 01 Identifying systems and processes currently in place to capture suggestions from employees Capturing Ideas– An Introduction Any organization which has even an iota of inclination towards Innovation needs a set of idea systems or programs to capture every type of idea. The traditional suggestion system had something equivalent to these lines, but it had a few major drawbacks of which the most serious one was that – all ideas, be small or big, was managed and rewarded in the same manner. Some or most methods such like those appearing immediately after this paragraph, needs to be put into operation Small Ideas – Which permits the submitter (working with resources in his/her area) to resolve the idea by him/herself. Recognitions and/or awards may be the compensation modes. Large Ideas – Receive recognition and/or awards and require large involvement of Capital or are well-beyond the ability of a submitter and supervisor to resolve. These may be passed onto a team to resolve. Innovative Ideas – Are those that spur......

Words: 11333 - Pages: 46

Impact of Csr on Employee Motivation

...Case Study: Impact of CSR on employee motivation Abstract: The workforce is a unique and irreplaceable possession of an Organization and it is absolutely necessary to keep them motivated at all times for continuous development and growth. The purpose behind this research is to help modern day companies realize the importance of CSR and how it can help to enhance the economic prosperity of an organization while motivating the workforce at the same time. Data collection is carried out with the aid of two questionnaires. Each questionnaire consists of 20 questions in the context of CSR and Employee Motivation. Data Analysis is completed with the assistance of IBM SPSS. The result of this research gives us understanding about the roles of CSR and the characteristics responsible behind employee motivation. Apparently the employees find it utterly encouraged whenever the Top Management involves them in decision making, concerning issues of the organization. The employees are fairly satisfied with their salary, the system of leaves they are provided with and their responsibilities. INTRODUCTION: Indian Oil is known to be the national oil flagship company of India with interests in business straddling the whole value chain of hydrocarbon – from refining, transportation of pipeline and marketing of products of petroleum to exploration and production of crude oil and gas, marketing of natural gas and petrochemicals. It is the leading Indian corporate, according to the Fortune “Global......

Words: 2526 - Pages: 11

The Impact of Organizational Change, Structure and Leadership on Employee Turnover: a Case Study

...Business Case Studies – January 2008 Volume 4, Number 1 The Impact Of Organizational Change, Structure And Leadership On Employee Turnover: A Case Study Steven H. Appelbaum, Concordia University, Canada André Mitraud, MBA, Canada Jean-François Gailleur, MBA, Canada Marcello Iacovella, MBA, Canada Raffaele Gerbasi, MBA, Canada Victoria Ivanova, MBA, Canada ABSTRACT Purpose - To provide the management team at BTSA Ltd with a practical guideline in managing organizational change through a designated lead change agent. Design/Methodology/approach - This guideline was developed by analyzing various organizational behaviour variables which included organizational structure, leadership and organizational culture. The objective of the case study is to provide a pragmatic approach to dealing with transformational change, particularly the role and responsibility of leadership. Findings – This case identifies a distinct correlation between each above stated variables and productivity/citizenship factors among employees. As a result of the takeover by an international conglomerate, BTSA Ltd was facing major changes and sustained a high level of employee turnover within the company, including the abrupt departure of their lead change agent. This resulted in a sharp decrease in TQM initiatives and major slowdown in R&D projects. The key findings have determined the core elements which explained the turnover issue and the impact of organizational change (for a small Canadian based......

Words: 8024 - Pages: 33

Employee Motivation

...An Understanding how the Team’s motivation can be improved Abstract This paper examined how the teams motivation improved as a way of understanding the problems of individuals as a member of organizations or teams. Findings suggest in order to motivate people to higher levels they should satisfy needs in defferent levels effort are key to higher employee motivation. Introduction [pic][pic] Whether in the sports field or in the workplace, or even amongst members of a community, effective teamwork can produce ridiculous results. However, working successfully as a team is not as easy as it may seem. Effective teamwork certainly does not just happen automatically; it takes a great deal of hard work and compromise. Effective team working is an essential ingredient for organisational success and successful teams can transform an organisation, it greatly increase outputs and deliver on organisational objectives. The composition of teams, how they work together, how they are motivated and the quality of leadership within teams are just some of the elements that contribute to making a successful organisation. Methodology We all know that in every team or organization there is always a conflict arises and I would say ninety percent of the common problems within teams, are easily recognisable. In this circumstances an organization or a manager should be able to motivate their staff because for me, team motivation is very important aspect in the workplace. In my own...

Words: 1776 - Pages: 8

Impact of Motivation on Employees Performance an additive relationship between externally mediated rewards and rewards which arise out of task performance itself. Therefore, if either one or both types of reward outcomes can be increased, total motivation or performance behaviors can be increased. In the late 1940’s a psychology professor called Harry F. Harlow (Harlow, Harlow & Meyer 1950) conducted one of the first true intrinsic motivational experiments ever performed, using a simple puzzle where a rhesus monkey needed to perform 3 simple tasks in a specific row to complete it. A simple task for a human, but a much more complex task for a little monkey. The experiment was performed on 12 primates over a 3-week period. Almost immediately the monkeys were able to solve the puzzle and they continued to solve it every time they were near it, without receiving any kind of rewards or recognition from doing so. Nobody showed the rhesus monkeys how to solve the puzzle or taught them that they even could solve it, but they still did it. Harlow concluded that it must have been due to an internal biological motivator that gave the monkeys a satisfaction or enjoyment from solving the puzzle. The experiment was repeated, but this time the monkeys were rewarded with a raisin every time they solved the puzzle. To his astonishment the monkeys started to make more errors and they solved the puzzle with less frequency than when no rewards was given. It was almost as if the reward reduced the monkeys motivation, lowering......

Words: 25213 - Pages: 101

Impact of Motivation on Employee Performance

...Global Advanced Research Journal of Management and Business Studies Vol. 1(4) pp. 126-133, May, 2012 Available online Copyright © 2012 Global Advanced Research Journals Full Length Research Paper Impact of Motivation on the working performance of employees- A case study of Pakistan. Akbar Ali1, Maira Abrar2 , Jahanzaib Haider 1 Bahaudin Zakariya University, Multan, Sub-Campus, Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan. Tel: 92-331-7304678, 2 3 Bahaudin Zakariya University, Multan, Sub-Campus, Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan. Bahaudin Zakariya University, Multan, Sub-Campus, Dera Ghazi Khan, Pakistan. Tel: 92-331-3312626, Accepted 10 April, 2012 Motives are key to human behavior. It plays an important role in performance and other activities and as such the manager should know what motivation is and how subordinates can are motivated towards performance. This study investigates the role of motivation on employees’ performance as the history of explaining human or animal behavior is not new.” why did one do what one did “had been the subject of working even in the past, some human behavior was explained as an outcome of demos impedance and this explanation was unscientific. Efforts were also made to determine principles which could explain human behavior. McDougall emphasized that man’s social behavior can be explained in terms of instincts which was later on criticized. Freud used “unconscious metal process” to explain behavior......

Words: 3951 - Pages: 16

Employee Motivation

...BUSINESS Dissertation Effect of Work Motivation on Employment Satisfaction (Case Study of Employees at Tesco) Name: Student Registration: Module Leader: Workshop Tutor: Due Date: Executive Summary List of Abbreviations List of Tables and Figures Table of Contents Executive Summary 2 List of Abbreviations 3 List of Tables and Figures 4 CHAPTER 1 7 INTRODUCTION 7 1.1. Background of the Study 7 1.2. Rationale for the Study 9 1.3. Problem Statement 10 1.4. Research Objectives 10 1.5. Summary 10 CHAPTER TWO 11 LITERATURE REVIEW 11 2.1. Introduction 11 2.2. How Motivation can Enhance Performance 12 2.3. Factors Affecting Employee Motivation 12 2.4. Motivating Employees at the Workplace 13 2.5. Theories of Motivation 14 2.5.1. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Theory 14 2.5.2. Herzberg’s Two Factor Theory 15 2.5.3. PERMA model 17 2.5.4. Financial 18 2.5.5. Non-financial 19 CHAPTER 3 21 METHODOLOGY 21 3.1. Introduction 21 3.2. Research Design 21 3.3. Population of the Study 21 3.4. Sample Frame 22 3.4.1. Questionnaire Instrument 22 3.4.2. Data Collection 24 3.5. Validity and Reliability 25 3.7. Data Analysis 25 CHAPTER FOUR 26 DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS 26 4.1. Introduction 26 3.2. Report on Findings of Specific Objectives 27 3.3. Report on Findings of General Objectives 29 CHAPTER 5 31 CONCLUSION 31 REFERENCES 33 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1.1. Background of the......

Words: 7367 - Pages: 30

Employee Motivation

...Employee motivation In any business having a team of highly motivated employees is crucial to business success. Often times several myths persist especially among new managers and supervisors in terms of how to motivate employees. Webster dictionary defines Motivation as motivating force; incentive. Most leadership books define motivation as an inner drive to satisfy a need. (qtd Clinton O. Longenecker 2) This is powerful because people are driven and tend to exert effort when their job satisfies a need important to them. Although employers are encouraged to motivate their workers, motivation truly begins within. Innate motivation is something that is self generated and can be changed when there is willingness from the person. Just because one has the talents and gifts doesn’t mean he or he will be motivated to use that skill. Christine Robertson says, “Managers who take time to learn about intrinsic motivation will discover what motivated abilities are within their workers. Managers can then structure jobs to take advantage of these motivations leading to better productivity, creativity and happier workforce as the job will be lined up with their personal gifts and talents”. Employees need to hear from leadership; be it how the company is performing, how the employees are doing performance wise. Most employees appreciate feedback and feel part of a team when they are informed. Without regular motivation, the workers can lose interest in their job, management and......

Words: 1217 - Pages: 5

Gamesmaster UK April 2012 | Switzerland | W5 Benchmark Cwv-101