Christianity and the Concept of Capital Punishment

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By yorel
Words 2274
Pages 10

Yorel Warr SIN: HISTORY OF AN IDEA November 13, 2013

The concept of capital punishment/death penalty forces Christians and non-Christians alike to question their morality. The idea that humans have the right to take life from those whom society have deemed undeserving of one is of constant debate. Many Christians find it easy to accept this practice for the worst of criminals. So one is left to question rather this practice of “an eye for an eye” as described in the Holy Scripture is appropriate or if it is just outright murder (sin). My perspective lies somewhere in the middle. On one hand I do not believe any human being has the right to take another’s life, yet on the other hand, there are some crimes so heinous that there seems to be only one appropriate punishment. In this paper I will examine the Christian perspective, practical applications and moral implications. DEATH PENALTY AND MORALITY
Some people believe that if there were no death penalty than our country would fall into anarchy. The death penalty, in their mind seems to be moral in the sense that it treats the defendant as a “free moral actor” in control of his/her own destiny. Dr. Ernest Van Den Hagg of Fordham University is an outspoken advocate of the death penalty. He stated that
"Common sense, lately bolstered by statistics, tells us that the death penalty will deter murder... People fear nothing more than death. Therefore, nothing will deter a criminal more than the fear of death... life in prison is less feared. Murderers clearly prefer it to execution -- otherwise, they would not try to be sentenced to life in prison…...

Similar Documents

Capital Punishment

...losing their right to life. Also, what about the innocent people, even though it isn’t many, they get killed because of simple mistakes in the justice system. Where capital punishment is used such mistakes cannot be put right. From personal research, I found that in the United States of America, 116 people were found innocent since 1973 and released from death row. These were just the lucky ones, the rest were not found innocent and were sentenced to the death. The U.S Catholic conference said: “We cannot teach that killing is wrong by killing.” They are saying that by using killing as a consequence we are just stooping to their level of low. We are just being a bad as them and if we kill surely we deserve the death penalty also. Also, crimes other than murder, do not receive a punishment that mimics the crime; rapists are not punished by sexual assault, and people found guilty of assault are not beaten up. The death penalty can actually upset more people by killing the offender. You have the family, and the friends to think about. Yes, they killed the victim and they obviously have their family and friends to, but by killing them are we actually teaching them anything? For much of history, Christianity has accepted that capital punishment was necessary. But, now some Christians are arguing that Christianity should support life. For the death penalty: “Whoever sheds the blood of a man, by man shall his blood be shed.” (Genesis 9:6) This teaching is saying that if......

Words: 2174 - Pages: 9

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment As can be seen on a map produced by “The Economist” in March 2012, there are only a few number of countries in the world which sentence criminals to death, and even fewer which actually execute those criminals. But, also looking at this map, one can see that the distribution of these practices is mostly regional. Along with the regional distribution, how does religion play into the disparity between those countries who kill their felons, and those which do not? (Most information in this discussion, and all quotes within, are from each reference on the particular religion listed on the last page.) [pic] Islam The Muslim religion supports capital punishment. But, in the Qur’an, there are only two particular cases where the death penalty is supported: intentional murder, and spreading mischief in the land. The Islamic religion holds harsh punishment as a deterrent for serious crimes. This is the way that this particular religion balances the sacristy of life and punishment of crimes. Also, there is no support for vigilantes, and the court is the only approved way of meting out the punishment. Only courts of law are supposed to carry out this charge, as the “spirit of the Islamic penal code is to save lives, promote justice, and prevent corruption and tyranny.” One could infer from this that Muslims look down on those who take the law into their own hands. In the case of intentional murder, the family of the victim has the option to......

Words: 1157 - Pages: 5

Capital Punishment

... Capital punishment is the death penalty for a crime. The concept includes the idea that a serious crime has been committed, and therefore the guilty person deserves to be executed. It also assumes that the government that carries out the sentence is legitimate, though the form of that government is not specified. Capital punishment, like so many other controversial subjects such as abortion, is related to several areas of life and society such as penology, sociology, law, but above all, theology. Anything that relates to life avid death is a theological subject. The heart of the issue is- What does the Holy Scripture teach? A person’s ethics are always based on his philosophy or theology, and that is related to his view of the authority of the Bible. The person who rejects the authority of the inspired Word of God will oppose what the Holy Scripture teaches about the death penalty. There are several reasons that people give for opposing capital punishment, but we do not agree even one of those viewpoints. Murder is to be punished by death because of the sanctity of human life for man was made in the image of God. Now a practical question is this: What is the purpose of capital punishment? A great variety of answers has been debated about the purpose of capital punishment, but ultimately the biblical purpose is related to the responsibilities of civil government. It is the purpose of government to punish those who do evil (2Pet.2:13), and capital punishment is......

Words: 306 - Pages: 2

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment Is No Resolution For Juvenile Offenders Juvenile Delinquents Should Not Have To Worry About Capital Punishment Tkemia S. Gibson 1000 Huntington Mews. Clementon, New Jersey 08021 Juvenile Delinquency Capital Punishment 2 Introduction/Abstract….. page 3 Judicial System…… page 5 Juvenile versus Adults…… page 6 Rehabilitation……. page 8 Conclusion……. page 9 Reference page… page 11 Capital Punishment 3 Introduction/Abstract In today’s society our judicial system has been trying to use rehabilitation, treatment services, and reformation to aide our youth in place of Capital Punishment. Capital Punishment was done away with on March 1, 2005. When dealing with medical research and therapist teams the process has become more opened to helping juveniles to overcome any negative behaviors in the legal system. Capital Punishment 4 Capital Punishment over the years has always been one of the most controversial topics that stay in communication with our legal system. In committing murder as a child, it is hard not to become judgmental in thinking that a child knows right from wrong. When thinking of a teenage child committing murder at times you may think do they really realize what they have just done and do they even know the consequences. My position is juveniles who commit the act of murder should not have to suffer the resolution of capital punishment because they are still children and their brains are......

Words: 2367 - Pages: 10

Capital Punishment

...Capital punishment, also called death penalty,  is the execution of an offender sentenced to death after conviction by a court of law of a criminal offense. The practice of executing people for certain crimes is very old; in fact, the term itself dates to a Latin root, capitalis, which means “of the head,” a reference to a common execution method used in Roman times. Currently 58 nations actively practice it, 97 countries have abolished it, and the remainders have not used it for 10 years or allow it only in exceptional circumstances such as wartime. However, It is a matter of active controversy in various countries as it violates human rights. What Is Capital Punishment Capital punishment is a practice in which prisoners are executed in accordance with judicial practice when they are convicted of committing what is known as a capital crime or capital offense. In other words, capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime. The judicial decree that someone be punished in this manner is a death sentence, while the actual process of killing the person is an execution. History Of Capital Punishment Early Laws The first established death penalty laws date as far back as the Eighteenth Century B.C. in the Code of King Hammaurabi of Babylon, which codified the death penalty for 25 different crimes. The death penalty was also part of the Fourteenth Century B.C.'s Hittite Code; in the......

Words: 4497 - Pages: 18

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment Capital punishment is defined as, “the use of the death penalty to punish wrongdoers for certain crimes” (Gaines & Miller, p. 269). This type of punishment is the ultimate consequence for the most heinous crimes, and one of the greatest controversial topics in the criminal justice system. Some believe that this penalty is not only barbaric, cruel and unusual, but argue that the average cost per execution is extraordinary, totaling multi-millions of dollars. Quite a few death row inmates, that are previously found guilty for capital crimes, are later found innocent and released from prison. Supporters of the death penalty believe in the concept of “an eye for an eye” or in Bill Maher’s words, “capital punishment works great. Every killer you kill never kills again.” Critics in the United States of America, as a civilized society that it is, believe that the most violent, atrocious, habitual offenders known to man receive a cruel and unusual punishment with inflicted “unnecessary pain” from execution by lethal injection. The injection is administered in a three-drug “cocktail”: the sedative, the paralytic, and finally the drug to stop the heart. After the sedative takes effect, the body’s sense of pain is deadened, subsequently leading to an easy, painless death. I don’t know what could possibly constitute a more humane or peaceful death than that of the widely used lethal injection to carry out an execution sentence. There are alternate......

Words: 1428 - Pages: 6

Capital Punishment

...CAPITAL PUNISHMENT Is it the only Justice for Killers? CAPITAL PUNISHMENT Is it the only Justice for Killers? Crime is literally universal. Convicts are basically a fragment of our society. But that does not mean that they loiter and linger amongst ourselves without any action being taken against them. Reducing crime and convicts is our liability, and we cannot disregard it. Getting the justly alleged to an impartial sentence is crucial. Certain crooks are compelled to do an offense since they have no other choice to live, but some in particular do it for the fun. I do not promote death punishment for everyone. An individual, who took bread from a grocery stock, certainly does not be worthy of a death penalty. Nonetheless, a serial killer, who murders people for amusing himself or for his own gain, absolutely justifies death penalty. The society’s garbage can be eliminated by continuously using the penalty of death. Everybody does not deserve to die, but there are some people who definitely do. I support death penalty for numerous reasons. Firstly, death penalty helps in diminishing crime and serves as a deterrent. Secondly, although death penalty is irreversible is true, but a wrongly convicted person is difficult to kill due to the numerous chances given to the convicted to provide evidence for his innocence. Thirdly, by the elimination of these criminals using death penalty, safety of the society is assured. Finally, I believe in "lex tallionis" - a......

Words: 1175 - Pages: 5

Capital Punishment

...Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment Capital punishment is a topic that anyone can count on to stir emotional discussions with plenty of opinions. In the world today, people commit horrific crimes daily. There are many who feel that those who carry out these terrible crimes deserve one fate: death. Capital punishment is used in reference to the death penalty that is issued in a judicial manner to execute those found guilty of a capital or hard offense. This according to our text is called legal punishment. Legal punishment is defined as the state-authorized imposition of some form of deprivation-of liberty, resources, or even life-upon a person justly convicted of a violation of the criminal law. (Stohr, pg 3) In this review of the pros and cons of the death penalty we will examine some different aspects of the process and allow the reader to form their own opinion. History The death penalty can be traced back a long time throughout history. The first established death penalty laws date back to the Eighteenth Century B.C. In the code of King Hammaurabi of Babylon, which gave the death penalty for 25 different crimes. This code expressed the well-known concept of lex talionis (the law of equal retaliation), which is further enunciated in the Mosaic code, the ancient law of the Hebrews, as “an eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth.” (Stohr, pg. 3) During the 18th century, many philosophers like Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham wrote influential writings on......

Words: 1654 - Pages: 7

Capital Punishment

...Joseph Bryan Professor Malloris Hum 3710 28 August 2014 Capital Punishment: The Botched Solution Capital punishment is the rightful means to rid our society of criminals incapable of living a civil life. It provides a sense of closure to victims yet may take a loved one from others. The methods of implementing capital punishment have evolved greatly over the years and are designed to be more ethical and humane in the United States. Whether it is a firing squad, hanging, electric chair, gas chamber, or lethal injection, the death penalty has been a swift solution to deter and resolve crimes. In a recent execution in Oklahoma a problem occurred that led to the 43 minute suffering of Clayton Lockett. The constitution protects the American people from cruel and unusual punishment which is debatable in this case after acknowledging he raped and murdered a young girl. I am a firm believer in the constitution as well as capital punishment and have no moral problem with how this execution was carried out. This botched execution has sparked immense pressure from people to bring an end to the death penalty. It is portrayed as inhumane and unnecessary especially when it does not go as planned. The people arguing against capital punishment claim that it costs upwards of $4.2 million dollars per death sentence and is cheaper to simply imprison them (To Execute or Not). Money is the main reason behind many states not utilizing the death sentence. The death penalty may also put......

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Capital Punishment

...Kevin Reasoner Professor Kraskin English 1101 December 8th, 2012 Capital Punishment Capital punishment is a debate our politicians argue each year with. Many people are for it and many are against it. Our very own Supreme Court still debate on this topic. If properly used right, capital punishment is good for society because it is a deterrence against future crimes and protect the rights of victims of malicious murders, capital punishment is a legal and an appropriate measure in the United States legal system. Capital punishment was reestablished in 1976 by the Supreme Court as an appropriate measure for murder cases. Since then, many murderers have been convicted and put to death for their awful crimes. With each execution of a murderer, society is a safer place. When a human makes the ultimate decision to commit a crime of murder, rape, child rape, and torture, would a life in prison term be fair. Prison's are for much less acts of crime and people who do the acts against fellow humans should be punished by capital punishment. Prisons and jails are used as a deterrent so that people in today’s' society will not perform an act against another human. If they do, they know the repercussions of the acts they are performing. Some people are clearly not mentally capable of knowing the difference between right and wrong and they are put into hospitals because of their sickness. The majority of society know the difference of right and wrong. Another form of a......

Words: 1741 - Pages: 7

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment What is Capital Punishment? Capital Punishment which is also known as the Death Penalty. Death Penalty is the infliction of the death penalty as punishment for certain crimes according In the following essay will show why Capital Punishment is implemented to our society. Capital Punishment in any form is acceptable according to the following to the following articles will help justify this concept. To some people Capital Punishment would be considered an act of cruel and unusual punishment; while for others it is a system that should be considered needed in all the States in order to keep the country more safe for the people. Many states within the U.S. have performed executions of convicts since the early 1600’s. Views on capital Punishment vary with people in different ways; there are various organizations within the country that have different opinions on the subject, and organizations such as Religions, Political, or Humanitarian have diverse perspectives on the Death Penalty. “The death penalty is also most commonly argued to be a violation of the right to life or of the "sanctity of life." Many national constitutions and international treaties guarantee the right to life. the right to life demands that a life only be taken in exceptional circumstances, such as in self-defense or as an act of war, and therefore that it violates the right to life of a criminal if she or he is executed, since this is purely murder by the State”......

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

Capital Punishment

...Sam LaMotte Intro to Ethics November 29th 2015 Should the death penalty be abolished or retained? Capital punishment, or the death penalty, has been using for thousands of years. In the last two centuries, as people have realized the importance of human rights, debates over capital punishment have never stopped. More and more people join the campaign against capital punishment, while the others defend it. However, either abolishing the death penalty or retaining it has inextricable problems. My opinion is that capital punishment will vanish from this planet someday in the future, but for a long span of time from now, to abolish it or not depends on the social situations of different countries. People, who are against capital punishment, and advocate replacing it with lifetime imprisonment, list five reasons why they condemn it. Right to life is the first punch. In The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the constitution states, “Everyone has the right to life, liberty and security of person”. Among all the human rights, right to life is the cornerstone and the carrier of all the other human rights. Deprivation of the right to life is equivalent to deprivation of all the rights, which is inhumane in modern society. On the other hand, capital punishment is a product of the old barbaric concept “an eye for an eye, a life for a life;” and it is actually vengeance killing. Nowadays, most societies do not agree with vengeance killing. Such a brute act does nothing but......

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Capital Punishment

...history capital punishment has been opposed on many premises. In discussion forums across the world many individuals often cite deterrence of crime as a viable defense of capital punishment. However, comprehensive studies, including the 1994 FBI Uniform crime Report, indicate that capital punishment does not serve as a deterrent to crime. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, the death penalty not only does not deter crime- among states that have either abolished or instituted the death penalty crime and murder rates have remained unchanged. Additionally, Eric Pooley of Time magazine, in his research, reports that no proof exists to substantiate claims that capital punishment discourages crime by anyone other than the criminals whom are executed. Glenn Lammi, of the Washington Legal Foundation is quoted as saying that there are no convincing studies [connecting] the death penalty and the crime rate. Whitehead 3 In the absence of persuasive studies linking capital punishment and crime rates, who better to turn to than the individuals who walk the thin blue line- law enforcement officials may be better equipped to address this subject. Time magazine reports that 67% of polled police chiefs also did not believe that the death penalty deters [crime such as] homicide. According to a 1994 Government Accounting Office report (GAO) substantial evidence indicates that courts have been unfair in death sentencing. The 1990 GAO report, summarizing numerous capital punishment......

Words: 2908 - Pages: 12

Capital Punishment the crime, then he should be indeed big enough to take the punishment that follows. “Capital punishment, the death penalty, or execution is the sentence of death upon a person by the state as a punishment for a crime.” ( Basically Capital Punishment is the country’s major punishment, for what they consider to be the most major crimes. It is a subject of active disagreement and controversy in various countries and positions in the argument can vary with a single switch in political hierarchy. To count there are about fifty eight countries that still recognizes Capital Punishment. Surprisingly most of the European and Asian Countries are the ones prohibit the use of Capital Punishment. And oddly even though most of the world physical land masses rebukes Capital Punishment, most of the world’s population still resides in countries that still strongly agree with the use of Capital Punishment. But here in The Bahamas, our situation is quite a special one. We are a free independent country, our laws say that we recognizes the use of Capital Punishment in the country, it obvious that a country cries for it, but the dilemma is that it is not being carried out. But the question raised is why? What is the hold up, and how do the Bahamian people feel about the whole situation? Chapter 1 “Capital Punishment in the Bahamas; Gone but not forgotten” Capital Punishment in The Bahamas has been a practice long before the ages, from...

Words: 3338 - Pages: 14

Capital Punishment

...Capital Punishment  Many distinctive doctrines in criminal law originated in efforts to restrict the number of capital crimes and executions. For instance, in the late 18th century, when all murder in the United States was punishable by death, Pennsylvania pioneered in dividing murder into two categories. The state enacted laws that authorized punishment of first-degree murder by death, while second-degree murder was punishable by imprisonment only. Elsewhere, penal codes uniformly required death for certain serious crimes. In these jurisdictions, discretionary powers to commute death sentences gradually expanded. (A commutation substitutes a lesser penalty for a more severe one—for example, replacing execution with a life sentence.) Today in many nations, including Turkey and Japan, the death penalty remains legal but the number of executions has declined over time.  Although many jurisdictions limited imposition of the death penalty, no government had formally abolished capital punishment until Michigan did so in 1846. Within 20 years Venezuela (1863) and Portugal (1867) had formally eliminated the practice as well. By the beginning of the 20th century the death sentence had been abolished in a handful of nations, such as Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Norway, and The Netherlands. Although not formally eliminated, it had fallen into disuse in many others, including Brazil, Cape Verde, Iceland, Monaco, and Panama. The defeat of the Axis powers provided a foundation......

Words: 1760 - Pages: 8

Lao People's Democratic Republic | Властелин колец: Братство кольца | 205 gti 1600