Conscience and Moral Judgement

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By jonnodw
Words 1262
Pages 6
Over the years, psychologists have marvelled at the mind’s ability to process external action, discriminate it, identify it, and to make moral, conscious decisions. The development of psychology and the understanding of the human mind has been a crucial step forward in the development of civilisation, as psychological insights have proved to be beneficial in improving everyday life, helping us in avoiding things that cause stress, to be more efficient in our thinking, and to make better decisions to a certain degree. There is significant importance behind the understanding of the behaviours of the mind and cognitive processes of which it will experience, though it is the conscience that has been questioned whether it alone can be considered as a satisfactory moral authority for making ethical decisions. The answer to this lies within one’s own interpretation of what conscience actually is, though through consideration of various theories, conscience can be classed as a viable moral authority. There are various sources which define conscience in different manners; therefore this essay will review a selection of theories produced by Sigmund Freud, and Thomas Aquinas, whilst providing alternate viewpoints inclusive of those of the Islamic religion derived from scripture and also making reference to law and the effect it has on making moral decisions.

Conscience can be defined as “the complex of ethical and moral principles that controls or inhibits the actions or thoughts of an individual”, though how we develop these ethical and moral principles will allow one to gather an understanding of how the conscience operates (Encarta Dictionary).
Sigmund Freud was a Jewish psychiatrist famed as the founding father of psychoanalysis, which essentially describes that human behaviour, experience, and cognition are largely determined by irrational drives which are…...

Similar Documents

Conscience Is the Voice of God Within Us

...‘Conscience is the voice of God within us’ Discuss In order to discuss whether the conscience is the result of the voice of God within us or whether in fact it is the result other environmental or biological factors we must firstly understand what a conscience is. Conscience is defined as a ‘direct intuitive awareness of right and wrong’ and therefore it is a ‘way of selecting moral ideas, resolving conflict and deciding which will work or not’. The conscience itself has three main functions, the first is that it has a decision-making function; this is seen as the most important function as it decides between right and wrong, the second is that it has a imperative functions; that is it commands and the third is that it has a reflective function; that is that it reflects on former decisions and considers the consequences of actions. However the question raised within this essay is whether our conscience comes from the voice of God within us, therefore is it acquired from God and is the result of an internal influence or is it required as a result of environmental factors, therefore is formed from an external influence whether this is from our parents or our own life experiences. Within this essay I shall discuss the theories in favour of the conscience being the voice of God within us (focussing on Butler, Augustine and Newman), and those that instead propose that it is acquired from other sources whether this is through our reason (Aquinas) or in our early childhood......

Words: 3118 - Pages: 13

Judgement Call

...could possibly be caught. If that were to happen, the attorney would be the one who ended up in prison. Because of Double Jeopardy, Jane wouldn’t be retried for murder, but the attorney could end up with several years to serve. Would it have been worth it then? Possibly, for knowing that he/she did the right thing, but then their life, children’s lives, family and loved ones would end up suffering. It may be worth it though knowing he/she had saved someone’s life. Egoism – The attorney could look at their actions for forging Jane’s signature as a definite way to free her, thereby enhancing their own career as an attorney. Probably a high profile case, getting Jane off without the worry of getting a guilty criminal off would ease their conscience and build their career at the same time. Conversely, if they get caught, they get disbarred and jailed. Utilitarianism – By forging Jane’s signature and getting her off, she’s one less innocent person who has been jailed unfairly thereby lessening the issue of jail over-crowding. One less prisoner also means less tax payer dollars for local tax payers. Deontology – Jane didn’t do anything wrong and only the wrong circumstances are preventing her from staying out of prison. Especially for paying in cash she was foolish for not have gotten a receipt. She was also irresponsible for not signing the guest registry (which is also the clerk’s fault for not catching it) but neither of those actions justify her being sentenced to......

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

Assess the View That Conscience Should Be Obeyed

...view that conscience should be obeyed Conscience is an incredibly powerful thing that many people do not understand. It has the ability to shape the way we behave and control how we feel over certain situations which includes feeling guilty. Understanding what conscience is and how it is developed is an important thing as it could shape the way we behave and effectively change how society is. Aquinas linked the conscience to God, it isn’t God telling us what to do but it is a faculty of God given reason. Aquinas described the conscience as “the mind of man making moral judgement”. Aquinas saw the conscience as the natural ability of a rational human being to understand the difference between right and wrong, and to apply the most basic moral principles to particular situations. Aquinas believed that the conscience contains two essential parts: Synderesis and Conscienta. Synderesis refers to the rational principles on which moral decisions are based; it is ‘right reason’ which stems from our natural tendency to do good and shy away from evil. The other essential part of the conscience is conscienta which refers to the moral judgement that a person makes based on those principles. Aquinas points out that your conscience should always be followed even if it leads them to do the wrong thing; the conscience can go wrong however by following your conscience, it makes a person morally blameless. Despite a person being morally blameless if they follow their conscience, a......

Words: 1108 - Pages: 5

Assess the View That Conscience Should Be Obeyed

...the view that conscience should always be obeyed (35 marks). Conscience can be seen as a form of moral judgement of right and wrong. The term is often used in everyday life to refer to thoughts that challenge negative ideas. Philosophers such as Newman and Butler believe that it should strictly be obeyed, obedience being the act of following regardless of the circumstances, as conscience is God-given. However, psychologists such as Freud and Piaget believe otherwise, that conscience is not necessarily from God but is developed from our moral development and the influence society has on us. Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, focused on an individual’s past and its subconscious influence in later life, particularly adulthood. He argued that conscience is based around guilt. Freud suggested that our conscience is the voice of our individual desires that must be satisfied. In particular, he emphasised the importance of sexual desires and argued that we feel guilty or dissatisfied as individuals if we go against our conscience. He reasoned that through early developmental years, we learn values that influence our moral awareness in what is right and wrong, which develop for later on in our lives. Freud divided human consciousness into three separate elements: the ego, the id and the super-ego. According to Freud, the id contains our emotional and physical needs and is the more selfish aspect of our personality. On the other hand, the super-ego is the moral aspect......

Words: 1429 - Pages: 6

An Examination of Conscience

...An Examination of Conscience         I believe in a loving Savior Who forgives my sins and Who gives me the grace to become a saint. Jesus Christ, through the ministry of His priests, does both in the Sacrament of Penance. "As the Father hath sent Me, I also send you ... Receive ye the Holy Ghost. Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained." (John 20:21-23) "If your sins be as scarlet, they shall be made as white as snow." (Isaias 1:18) "I am not come to call the just, but sinners." (Matt. 9:13) "Men have received from God a power not granted to angels or archangels. Never was it said to the heavenly spirits, ‘Whatsoever you shall bind and unbind on earth shall be bound and unbound in heaven.’ The princes of this world can only bind and unbind the body. The power of the priest extends further; it reaches the soul, and it is exercised not only in baptizing, but still more in pardoning sins. Let us not blush, then, to confess our faults. He who blushes to discover his sins to a man, and who will not confess, shall be covered with shame on the Day of Judgment in the presence of the whole universe." (St. John Chrysostom, Treatise on Priests, Bk. 3)         Prayer before Confession: O Lord, grant me light to see myself as Thou dost see me, and the grace to be truly and effectively sorry for my sins. O Mary, help me to make a good confession.         How to Confess: First examine your conscience well, then tell......

Words: 3486 - Pages: 14

Criticaly Evaluate the Claim That Conscience Is Dictated by Society and Upbringing.

...Critically evaluate the claim that conscience is dictated by society an upbringing. Jean Piaget first postulated the idea that conscience is not the voice of God but a result from our upbringing and what we learn. He was a developmental psychologist who studied the behaviour of children. He theorised that children go through different stages in their understanding of the world around them, and it is not until the age of 10 that young people have a fully developed sense of morality. This scientific approach is very plausible because it is based on observations, and makes predictions that can be tested. For example, you can describe two different situations to a six year old, one of which is someone lying and a minor bad consequence arising, the other is someone accidentally causing a very negative consequence. For a six year old, the latter case would ‘make mummy more cross’ because their understanding is that something is bad because it hurts or upsets people. Ask an older child, and they will accurately say that a parent would be more cross with the child who told a lie. Piaget is showing that conscience is something we learn as we grow and develop. This theory seems to contradict Newman’s ideas. Newman was an intuitionist, believing that conscience is ‘the voice of God’. He believed that when faced with a moral decision, we get a sense of moral direction from God, which we can either listen to or ignore. Conscience is an ability to detect the right course of action. For...

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

Moral Development

...Stages of Moral Development According to Kohlberg Stages of Moral Development by Lawrence Kohlberg (1971) I. Pre-conventional Level At this level, the child is responsive to cultural rules and labels of good and bad, right or wrong, but he interprets the labels in terms of either the physical or hedonistic consequences of action (punishment, reward, exchange of favors) or the physical power of those who enunciate the rules and labels. The level is divided into the following three stages: Stage 0: Egocentric judgement. The child makes judgements of good on the basis of what he likes and wants or what helps him, and bad on the basis of what he does not like or what hurts him. He has no concept of rules or of obligations to obey or conform independent of his wish. Stage 1: The punishment and obedience orientation. The physical consequences of action determine its goodness or badness regardless of the human meaning or value of these consequences. Avoidance of punishment and unquestioning deference to power are values in their own right, not in terms of respect for an underlying moral order supported by punishment and authority (the latter is stage 4). Stage 2: The instrumental relativist orientation. Right action consists of what instrumentally satisfies one's own needs and occasionally the needs of others. Human relations are viewed in terms such as those of the market place. Elements of fairness, reciprocity, and equal sharing are present, but they are......

Words: 5329 - Pages: 22

‘Conscience Is the Voice of God’ Discuss.

...‘Conscience is the voice of god’ Discuss. Most people would agree that conscience is the reasoned voice inside us that guides and tells us what we should and shouldn’t do. However peoples views on the origins of conscience can differ a lot; whether people belief its Gods doing or whether it’s innate or even whether it is acquired. In this essay I will be showing the viewpoints of various philosophers with their beliefs on whether conscience is or isn’t the voice of God. Ultimately I believe that conscience is not the voice of God. John Henry Newman believed that conscience was the voice of God, and that following the suggestions of your conscience gives the same significance as to follow God’s laws and values. Newman used conscience as proof for the existence of God. He said that the fact that we feel guilty, even when it is impossible for anyone to know what we have done, for example, having bad thoughts about someone, proves that ‘there is one to whom we are responsible to’. This feeling we have of being accountable was how Newman saw our conscience. He believed that there must be a God that we are accountable to and the reason we feel guilty for wrong thoughts or actions was because we all knew that someone, who Newman believed was God, was looking down on us and we had to impress him in a sense. However there was a flaw to his theory as he didn’t consider people that perhaps don’t ever feel guilty. Also those who don’t believe in God – do they not have a......

Words: 1152 - Pages: 5

Assess the View That Conscience Is Not the Voice of God, but Is Learned. (35 Marks)

...“I have noticed my conscience for many years, and I know it is more trouble and bother to me than anything else I started with.”(Mark Twain) People are often advised to follow their conscience because by definition it is “Our sense of moral right and wrong.”(Oliphant) It is a moral faculty or sense that leads individuals to believe that actions are morally wrong or right. Yet it can lead on person to choose war and another to feel this is morally abhorrent. There is a lot debate regarding where the conscience comes from, whether it be by a God given ability which is pushed forwards by biblical teachings, or from the sense of guilt we feel when we go against our conscience according to Sigmund Freud. “The Conscience is a difficult notion to understand and even more difficult to explain how it operates,” (Richard Gula) therefore there are many definitions of conscience and there are many philosophical theories about conscience and it connection with moral decision making. Firstly an argument for the conscience, which is the voice of God, comes from Augustine of Hippo, who said that “Men see the moral rules written in the book of light which is called Truth from which all laws are copied.” (De Trinitate, Augustine of Hippo). He was a theologian and believed that the conscience is God’s love poured forth to human beings, thus it is when God speaks to the individual, therefore he is arguing that the conscience is the voice of God and it reveals itself in solitary moments thus is......

Words: 1846 - Pages: 8


...Hana Resa Ananda 141521019 Judgement Judgement is the final step in process of knowing. Before we’ve been learned together about conceptualization as the second process of knowing, and conceptualization considered apart from judgement. Simply allows to us to think the materials provided by sensation and perception. Conceptualization is the beginning of understanding, in that it classifies and relates as such-and-such the this-here-now of sensibility tentatively and hypothetically. The classification must correct and to be verified, that is, it must be shown that the evidence is sufficient to warrant the assertion in each case “it is so”. Only then is knowing complete, for only then is any truth-claim made. Judging Judging is the act of the mind by which a proposition is grasped as virtually unconditioned, that is, as having sufficient evidence for its assertion as true. The first is composition and division. This refers to the act of formulating a proposition in the form: S is (not) P. Proportion is difference language but the meaning, for instance: x. The book is red y. The book is red, these two sentence are same but has difference meaning. Utterances: 2 utterences Propostion: 1 proposition The second role of judgement on this traditional presentation is precisely affirmation or denial of a proposition. Judgement in the full sense requires an answer to the question for reflection, although it supposes an answer to the question for intelligence. The......

Words: 302 - Pages: 2

Law and Conscience

...quality of things manifesting their conformity or non-coformity with the norm or criteria. (that which conforms is good or moral, that which do not conform is evil or immoral) ◦The subjective norm of morality – Conscience ◦The objective norm of morality – Law (natural) •Both natural law and conscience are rooted on Eternal Law, the ultimate norm, thus, there is only one norm. Loading... Conscience •The subjective/proximate norm of morality. ◦It is proximate because it is what directly confronts an action as good or bad. •Function: to examine/investigate, to judge, to pass punishment on our moral actions. ◦It approves & commends; reproaches & condemns; forbids & commands; accuses & absolves. •Synderesis – it is the quality by which man naturally perceives the truth of the self-evident principles of the moral order. Conscience - definition •Derived from the Latin words “con” plus “scientia” which means “with knowledge” of what is right or wrong or “trial of oneslf” both in accusation and in defense. •It is the “inner or little voice of God in man” crying out man’s moral obligations and telling him what to do and what to avoid in the moral order. •It is an act of the practical judgment of reason deciding upon an individual action as good and to be performed or as evil and to be avoided. Loading... Conscience - Kinds •Antecedent – judgment is passed before an action is performed. Consequent –......

Words: 3356 - Pages: 14

‘Assess the View That the Conscience Is Not the Voice of God but Learned’ Discuss.

...To assess this view that the conscience is not the voice of God but learned we have to consider what a conscience really is. Many define the conscience as a personal moral that guides us with moral and ethical issues, helping us to weigh up the more or less important ones. It is also shaped by the consequences from our actions and the lessons we learn. I take the stance of the statement disagreeing with the traditional religious view of a God-given conscience, our conscience is fabricated through our up bringing an environment and the reflection on past memories but the belief in God may affect how we respond and listen to our conscience. The proposition that the concept is not the voice of God but learned is supported by many psychologists. For instance Erich Fromm argued that all humans are influenced by external authorities such as Church leaders, parents and teachers who embed rules and guidelines into us and apply punishments for when with break them. These rules are sub-consciously archived by the individual that forms the basic of our conscience. The disobiendence and failings to follow these rules results in guilt which then leads us to the weakening of our power and more submissive responses to the authority. I see this as a strong, valid argument as we can see it happening in every day life. For example when children misbehave they show signs of guilt and shame. Also many murderers and criminals have had an unstable upbringing with their parents as unsuitable......

Words: 1251 - Pages: 6

Discuss the Claim That Conscience Allows People Too Much Freedom to Behave as They Wish

...Discuss the claim that conscience allows people too much freedom to behave as they wish (35 marks) There is great debate surrounding the idea that the conscience perhaps allows people too much freedom to behave as they wish or whether it is adequate as a guide, of course this debate is dependent on the definition used of conscience, an extremely subjective term. According to the Oxford English Dictionary a conscience is to be defined as ‘an inner feeling or voice viewed as acting as a guide to the rightness or wrongness of one's behaviour’ however this is the view of only some, and there is much debate around the meaning, ability and purpose of the conscience. Theist’s such as St. Thomas Aquinas and Joseph Butler point to God as the source of conscience in contrast to psychologists and sociologists such as Sigmund Freud who point to causes such as authoritative figures shaping our conscience. Equally they disagree on the role it plays, Freud for example suggested it is created as part of the unconscious mind, and believed that it arose as a result of bad experiences early in life, as well as disapproval from parents and society. Butler in contrast would name it ‘’our natural guide’’ given by god to help us act as a moral judge and use reasons to weigh up factors in a moral decision. In this essay I will assess the views of Aquinas, Butler, Fromm, and Freud in relation to the claim and my belief that the conscience does not allow too much freedom. Italian Dominican......

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6


...Moral and Ethical Dilemmas One of the most difficult trials I face in my life are ethical and moral dilemmas. They can be soul-wrenching and searching experiences that tax my character and cause me to really "put my money where my mouth is." Sometimes I'm quick to see ethical faults in others, but slow to see them in myself. Other times I see all to clearly my mistakes and wonder why I don't measure up. I believe one purpose for this life is to learn to act for ourselves. Learn to see a situation correctly and act righteously. In this paper I wish to discuss many of the thoughts I have had recently on setting a pattern for making ethical decisions throughout my life. I will present many of the traps I have fallen into or observed in others. Everyday I'm faced with decisions of right and wrong, most of which are easily and correctly dealt with. Sometimes however, decisions need to be made that are not easy or clear-cut. They require thought and often prayer. I like to draw on past experience to make comparisons that help give insight to new problems. Many times, however past experiences cannot be related to present problems and can confuse and obscure possibilities. Even the opinions or actions of friends faced with similar dilemmas may not be helpful. Often you feel pressured by piers that say, "it's no big deal", or "you'll understand later". It's important that I understand why a particular action or resolution is correct or incorrect. If I can't or don't it's difficult to......

Words: 1495 - Pages: 6

Wise Judgement

...Running head: WISE JUDGEMENT Wise Judgement Crystal Davila ENG 106 Survey of Literary Masterpieces University of Phoenix Daphne Matthews May 7, 2012 Wise Judgment There is this teenage girl Michelle who states that she is “in love” with her 17-year-old boyfriend. Her boyfriend is encouraging her to have sex with him saying that he will make sure they only have “protected” sex. The questions that come to my mind is what exactly is protected sex and how does she know she really is in love. At this age, do young adults really understand the true meaning behind love? There are five components of wise judgment and they can be applied to this scenario to understand what is happening and what can be done to help her understand how serious this situation can be. The first component to wise judgment is factual knowledge about matter of life. In this situation, does Michelle really understand what is at steak? This is similar to The Death of Ivan Ilyich when he states “What is the right thing?“ (Tolstoy, 2243). If not she should understand that correct information about protected sex. Even if someone has protected sex does not mean they are one hundred percent safe. Everything that is available for protective sex has warnings printed on them. Just because someone is in love does not mean they have to have sex. On the other hand, if Michelle was not ready and understood what can happen if she does give in to having sex with her boyfriend then she......

Words: 1414 - Pages: 6

Ek Hazaaron Mein Meri Behna Hai (2011) | Weihnachtsmann Co. KG (6) | Code Black