Ethical Challenges in Withdrawing Life Support

In: Other Topics

Submitted By ednarn
Words 1210
Pages 5
Ethical Challenges in Withdrawing Life Support

There are many serious issues for families to consider when faced with the prospect of removing life support for a loved one. My objective is to identify the key medical ethical considerations that are faced when considering the removal of life support for a patient. Then, I will draw some conclusions about the choices I would make if faced with the decision of having to remove life support for a member of my family.
It may be that the decision to withhold or withdraw life support is most likely to pit the hopes and fears of patients and their families against medical science and their physician. Patients are compelled by powerful emotions (such as guilt) or by adherence to religious or secular traditions to behave in certain ways that may conflict with medical advice.2 Honest discussions with patients and their families about the benefits and burdens of therapy and the medical uncertainty that exists are necessary to provide patients and families with the best opportunity to make informed decisions.
We know that honest direct communication is most important for patients and families faced to make life determining decisions. These health care workers must communicate within the medical ethics of their profession. Medical ethics is based on a four prima facie moral principles and attention to these principles' scope of application. The four prima facie principles are respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. “Prima facie,” a term introduced by the English philosopher W D Ross, means that the principle is binding unless it conflicts with another moral principle - if it does we have to choose between them.2 Respect for autonomy is the moral obligation to respect the autonomy of others in so far as such respect is compatible with equal respect for the autonomy of all potentially affected.…...

Similar Documents

Life Support

...The loss of a close one is never easy, and sometimes it hurts more than other times. You can never prepare yourself for the day when you have to make the decision to remove them off of life support when they are unable to make it for themselves. Not every situation will be the same, and you may not handle each one in the same manner. September 30th, 2007 was the day I had to let my mother go. That morning I had talked to one the many doctors and they had informed me that she was in multi organ failure, and there was no hope. So many thoughts, wishes, regrets, and emotions run through your mind faster than you can process or even recognize. The dreadful papers stare back at you and make you sick to your stomach. I received a call late one night when my mother was taken to the hospital. My mother was only 83 pounds when she entered the hospital. She had lost about 7 pints of blood, and was not keeping the blood in. The doctor told us when one is in multi-system organ failure; their body basically attacks itself and begins to shut down organ by organ. My mother was anorexic. She battled the disease her entire life so it was only a matter of time it caught up to her. Nothing could have prepared me for what I was about to go through the next few days, or what I was about to see in the next minutes. I walked into the room and saw a small, too skinny, frail woman that was in and out of consciousness. The only voice she responded to or recognized was her boyfriend’s,...

Words: 559 - Pages: 3

Legal Aspects of Life Support

...  Legal Aspects of Life Support   In "Legal Aspects of Withholding and Withdrawing Life Support from Critically Ill Patients in the United States and Providing Palliative Care to Them," authors John M. Luce and Ann Alpers, present this article to increase an understanding of the legal obligation of physicians and practitioners. Studies have shown that most patients, who die in intensive care units in the United States, deaths are related to the withholding and withdrawal of life support and also the administration of palliative care. The process through which various medical interventions are withheld or removed from patients with the expectation that the patient will die of an underlying illnesses is withholding and withdrawal of life support. The prevention or treatment of pain or providing comfort during suffering in terminally ill patients is palliative care. Physicians and practitioners are bound by ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, and nonmaleficence. This means their actions are done for the benefit of others and they must do no harm. There are laws that govern the legal aspects and requirements of these practices in which physicians and other practitioners may not be familiar. The limitations of life sustaining treatments vary from each state and are based on statutory and case law. The Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution protects a competent person’s right to proceed with treatment which includes nutrition and hydration. The legal......

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Life Support

...Ending Life Support There is a lot of controversy over the topic of ending life support. Should the decision be made by a doctor or the family members of the patient? http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1985-06-13/news/8502070415_1_karen-quinlan-life-and-death-brain-death http://ajrccm.atsjournals.org/content/162/6/2029.full http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC522828/ http://www.people-press.org/2006/01/05/strong-public-support-for-right-to-die/ Cases: Karen Quinlan Case, Barber v. Supreme Court Case, Cruzan Case, Gilgunn Case --Protected under the 14th amendment Autonomy- determining moral responsibility for one's actions Some people think that a patient’s death should be in the hands of the physician, if their condition isn’t consistent or advancing. A will is something that people use to make sure their desires are met if they are unable to make the decision by themselves. The idea of keeping a will was widespread in the 1990’s, the number of people that say they have a living will more than doubled from 12% in 1990 to 29% now (Peoplepress 1). But what about the other 71% of American’s? An accident can happen to anybody and if you aren’t able to make decision’s for yourself who is the person who will be making those decision’s for you. The regulations on the subject in the United States is that the patient or surrogate must be informed on the subject and can consent to or refuse all treatments given to them (Atsjournals 1). Life support would......

Words: 347 - Pages: 2

Withold/Withdraw Life Support

...Withdrawing/Withholding Life Support: Pros and Cons November 16, 2012 ABSTRACT When a person is being sustained by life support, families and loved ones are frequently confronted with the resolve about when to terminate these supports (Meeker, 2012). Recently it has turned into “pulling the plug” prior to death regardless of the tubes and machines keeping the patient alive. Withdrawal choices are informal and quietly decided. If these life-ending decisions were standardized and validated, maybe some of these safety measures can be useful to other choices approaching the idea of drawing life to a close, even for those who aren’t dependent on life-supports (Meeker, 2012). As we advance towards the twenty first century, it will become more common for us to be supported by equipment and medications the last few days or weeks of our lives. If some disease or condition that would, as a rule, take months or even years to bring death, the need for life-support could be longer. “Withdrawing life-sustaining treatment such as artificial ventilation means to discontinue it after it has been started. Withholding life-sustaining treatment means never starting it,” (Fremgen, 2012). If in fact we are being kept alive by any form of medical equipment, any choices made about the best time to die and the best means to allow our deaths should contain queries about what to do with the life-support systems in place, sustaining life (Lin, 2003). Withdraw/Withhold Life Support: Pros......

Words: 1259 - Pages: 6

Resolving Ethical Business Challenges

...Joseph's Ethical Problems 1.What are Joseph’s ethical problems? Ethical issues in this scenario include honesty, integrity, fairness, intimidating behavior, and bribes. Even though, the policy handbook does not specifically state that kickbacks are against the law, the sales personnel basically knows, that kickbacks are unethical because it leads to lower quality of product and increases customers’ prices. Joseph also learned that Carl takes money out of his commission for kickbacks. Giving and receiving kickback are serious crimes. A kickback is effectively a quid-pro-quo bribe, a collusive agreement, designed to help or influence an individual, company, or government entity. 2.Imagine that you are Joseph. Discuss your options. Since Joseph discovered an unethical issue, it is his responsibility to report the behavior. If I where him I would do all I could to resolve the issue by going through the chain of command first. By not reporting this incidence, he is putting his job on the line and most of all can lead to criminal charges. Joseph tried to solve the problem with Carl, who has a large amount of the company’s existing clientele sales, at a monthly meeting to try and solve the problem but was unsuccessful. Other options is to have a meeting with sales staff, with Kathryn present, regarding how the company will not tolerate any kind of unethical behavior and if anyone is caught, they will be fired on the spot. Also need to remind the sales team that...

Words: 338 - Pages: 2

Resolving Ethical Business Challenges

...1) What are the potential ethical issues faced by Acme Corporation? i. The ethical issue faced by Acme Corporation is that the comapany was facing a decline state in the culture. ii. The ethical issue faced by Acme Corporation was that few mistakes were allowed in the supplies industry because of there competitors. iii. The ethical issue faced by Acme Corporation was not connected to the right buyers. iv. The ethical issue faced by Acme Corporation is not having the knowledge on how to treat their consumers. 2) What should Acme do if there is a desire to make ethics a part of its core organizational values? • Must have means to practice social reponsiblity, while serving customers valuing, their employees and establishing trust with the public. Ethical conduct toward customer builds a strong competitive positon that has been shown to positivey affect business performance and product innovation. Also if generally accepeted that customer satisfaction is one of the most important factors in corporation, then the bussiness would become successful. The corporation must continue to develop and adapt products to keep pace with customers’ changing desires and perferences to develop long term relationships with its customers and stakeholders. 3) Identify the ethical issues of which Frank needs to be aware. • Franks needs to be aware of how to deal with personal moral dilemmas.also able to recognise the relationship between bussiness ethics and personal......

Words: 330 - Pages: 2

Ethical Dilemmas and Challenges in Counseling

...Some of the challenges about ethics and law related to my future counseling practice include imposing my own values, beliefs and ideals on clients, maintaining the competence and skills needed to effectively abide by said ethics and laws and deciphering how to take action when laws and ethics collide. Ethics are the philosophical underpinnings of human conduct, and it is important for counselors to uphold all aspects of ethics in order to provide the highest level of care and avoid charges of unethical conduct (Bradley & Hendricks, 2008). Two forms of ethics that exist are principle ethics and virtue ethics. Principle ethics embody moral principles that are widely agreed upon beliefs that make up helping professions. The six main moral principles include autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, justice, fidelity and veracity. The second form of ethics is virtue ethics. Virtue ethics revolve around personal characteristics and virtues and entail integrity, discernment, acceptance of emotion, self-awareness and interdependence with the community (Remley & Herlihy, 2014). According to Jennings, et al. (2005), one key to avoiding ethical dilemmas is by avoiding personal biases and views in client sessions. According the ACA Code of Ethics (2005), any personal views that are not aligned with counseling goals must be avoided, and counselors need to remain aware of these views and respect all forms of diversity when it relates to clients, trainees and research participants. Because...

Words: 1359 - Pages: 6

Hyundai Ethical Challenges

...What are the greatest ethical challenges for Hyundai? Over the years Hyundai has had its share of ethical challenges to overcome. Probably the most notable of these challenges was the prosecution and subsequent conviction of the Chairman, Chung Mong Koo in 2006 for embezzling funds. Chung was essentially responsible for turning Hyundai into the global success that it was and is today so this had an enormous impact on the future of the company. He was accused of making questionable deals that benefitted him and his son and he was sentenced to three years in prison; however in September of 2007 he was granted a suspension of the three year prison sentence due to the fact that his imprisonment and the impact on Hyundai would negatively affect the Korean economy. Chung promised to donate $1 billion if he was freed and in February 2008 he was re-elected as the Chairman of Hyundai Motors. According to the text, this behavior is that of an immoral manager. Chung was obviously not interested in what was “the right thing to do” but was more interested in his own best interests and that of his family. He put the reputation and image of Hyundai at risk. However, given the economy in Korea and the political issues that exist there he basically got a slap on the hand and was allowed to be reinstated. This ethical challenge of immoral behavior did have some impact on their reputation; however given the fact that they are still one of the leading auto makers in the world, obviously...

Words: 282 - Pages: 2

Ethical Challenges

...Ethical Challenges 1. You are an executive for a U.S. oil firm interested in forming a partnership with an Iranian oil producer. This will be a challenge because of the poor relations between the United States and Iran over the years. Since the early 1980s the United States has drawn fire from the business community for imposing economic sanctions (similar to an embargo) against Iran for primarily political reasons. Those sanctions disallow international trade and investment between U.S. and Iranian businesspeople. Business leaders in the United States would like the sanctions removed so they can be included in lucrative Iranian oil and gas deals in which firms from other countries are engaging. Other sanction opponents wonder if a policy of offering “all stick and no carrot” is undermining social and political change in Iran because the offending regime goes largely unpunished while ordinary citizens suffer. What arguments would you present to the U.S. government for removing sanctions on Iran? Do you think that one country, acting alone, can bring about reforms through the use of economic sanctions or embargoes? 2. You are the president of a sugar company based in southern Florida. Your firm is struggling lately to meet demand because of poor harvests in the Caribbean Islands, where your firm sources much of its raw product. Because of the Helms–Burton Act and the U.S. embargo on Cuba, your firm is not allowed to trade with Cuba. If the embargo were dropped, your firm......

Words: 429 - Pages: 2

Challenges and Prospects of Ethical Hacking

...Ethical /acking to ensure the sa,ety o, your computer system. /ere is a list o, 0ene,its that you can derive ,rom hiring *hite hat hackers4$. 3hite hat hackers increase the security levels o, computer systems. 1hey help increase your protection against 0lack hat hackers *ho are out to get your personal in,ormation.>. + *hite hat hacker prevents 0lack hat hackers ,rom entering your computer system. 3hite hat hackers employ high level computer science to evaluate and increase the security o, your computer system.?. 3hite hat hackers per,orm Ethical /acking to improve the de,ense mechanism o, your computer system.. 3hite hat hackers evaluate and assess the capa0ility o, your system to ,ind out potential loopholes and cracks that 0lack hat hackers can enter. 1hey make sure that your system is protected ,rom the sneaky techni2ues o, 0lack hat hackers.1hese are some o, the 0ene,its that *hite hat hackers can o,,er. %, *hite hat hackers per,orm Ethical /acking! 0lack hat hackers are their antithesis. Black hat hackers are illegal hackers that *ant to steal your personal in,ormation. Black hat hackers are 0ad ,or your system. 1hey *reck your system and prevent it ,rom per,orming *ell. Black hat hackers leave your system in sham0les. %t is 0est to hire a *hite hat hacker to create a line o, de,ense against 0lack hat hackers. The Ethical Hacker infl"ences processes and techni'"es in various ,ields namely • 'arketing A "ticking to ethical pricing and re,raining......

Words: 1053 - Pages: 5

Responding to Ethical Challenges

...“The Corporation” (http://informationclearinghouse.info/article12998.htm), is a documentary-style film about the ethical behavior of companies. It mainly focuses on American based multinational corporations. While the film has a clear and pervasive bias against corporate culture and behavior, it does raise many disturbing questions. As the views presented in the film are not necessarily outside of the mainstream, corporate entities should endeavor to understand the basis for the accusations, determine if there is any truth to them, formulate ways to change business behavior (if appropriate), and communicate the truth about intentions and actions in a clear and compelling way in the public forum. Section I: Five Principle Ethical Arguments The film argues that multinational corporations continue to act unethically in the following capacities: Human Rights Violations Corporations systemically use child labor. Conditions in depressed geographic areas constitute unsafe work conditions. Wages are intentionally kept at “poverty level” to increase investment and decrease cost. Corrupt authoritarian regimes are backed by multinationals to maintain control of the population for pure profit with wanton disregard to the acts of that regime. Human capital is regarded is expendable, and once the area is used up or wages rise too high, the corporation simply moves on to a cheaper locale. Intentional Environmental Harm Companies intentionally pollute the......

Words: 2015 - Pages: 9

Resolving Ethical Business Challenges

...Resolving Ethical Business Challenges Business Ethics Week 1 Everest University Amy Childers Resolving Ethical Business Challenges 1. What are the potential ethical issues faced by Acme Corporation? To me it seems that Frank is bribing Otis in order to with gifts in order to keep him as a buyer for Thermocare. Frank is thinking about himself and the praise and bonuses he is getting and really not focusing on the company and all that could result in the end. I think if other buyers knew this was going on it would probably hurt the company. Gifts should be given to everybody not just one person and in this scenario Otis seems to be the only one getting the personal gifts. That is probably why Frank is doing so well in the company and moving up faster than anyone else. Amber which is his boss is aware of the situation and she is covering up for Frank. Amber did invite everyone to Las Vegas for a Thank you party except Otis and his wife who went to Cancun. Not to mention the Adult Entertainment Club. To me this is acting unethically in the business. Amber’s ethical issues should be questioned as well. 2. What should Acme do if there is a desire to make ethics a part of its core organizational values? I think Acme should make sure to lay out all the rules and communicate them clearly to all of their staff. Also, let them know there will be consequences for those who don’t follow and abide by the rules for any reason. The main thing to let them know is no special...

Words: 679 - Pages: 3

Resolving Ethical Business Challenges

...BUS220 Ethical Business Challenge Chapter 5 Zyedego faces legal issues by hiring truck drivers such as if the employee has any infractions while on the job, which would cost the company money, the company would be responsible for that and whatever the insurance that covered the employee or company would not be willing to pay, such as in this instant, when there is a natural disaster, and insurance companies are not able to pay full claims. They also face ethical issues from the families of these or the employees themselves if something were to happen to the employee while on the job, whether the work was being required or not, that insurance companies may not be able to cover anything that happened, which could ultimately put that persons family at a great loss as well. Both of these mentioned issues could potentially have lawsuits against the company as well in worse case scenarios. I believe that Peter should recommend to Gwyn that unless she was able to get Dana to provide the correct documents required for her job, that they would try to hold her position until she could, without pay, or give her the option to go ahead and go to work for a competitor and offer her the severance pay. During a time that the company is not able to provide complete coverage if something were to happen to her on the job, and being that she is pregnant, could cost the company more money, especially if the insurance company required for her to prove her citizenship before being able to......

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Ethical Dilemmas for Nurses on End of Life Issues

...ETHICAL DILEMMAS FACING NURSES ON END-OF-LIFE ISSUES BASED ON CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS HELD IN ELDORET, KENYA Author: Kamau S. Macharia: BScN (Moi), MSc (studying) Nursing Leadership & Health Care Systems Management (University of Colorado, Denver), Higher Dip. Critical Care Nursing (Nbi). Graduate Assistant, School of Nursing & Biomedical Sciences, Kabianga University College (A Constituent College of Moi University), . P 0 Box 2030 20200 Kericho, Kenya , Tel +254 722224577, Email: symomash@gmail.com ETHICAL DILEMMAS FACING NURSES ON END-OF-LIFE ISSUES BASED ON CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS HELD IN ELDORET, KENYA ABSTRACT Problem Statement: A conference to discuss on ethical dilemmas is thought to be a good way of airing out issues. It is unfortunate that at times a patient in our care may die no matter what we do. Profound ethical questions on end of life issues confront the medical personnel as they watch and wait helplessly. This paper touches on ethics, law, social and public policy as they affect nursing practice. Setting: This is a conference proceedings report augmented with a case study of Nelly from a local setting and compares it with two others from elsewhere which were also presented during the conference. Conference was organized by Federation of African Medical Students Associations (FAMSA), Eldoret 2011. The author was a......

Words: 5645 - Pages: 23

Ethical Challenge

...Mike should identify who will primarily be affected by his ethical dilemma (in this case and Dianne).He must reach out to her and explain the situation 3. Mike checks down the actual occured time and simply tells his senior(Alex) about how he was not comfortable with eating time. What are the pros or potential upside of each alternative you listed above? Alternative 1: Dianne may be impressed by him on finishing on time and Mike and Alex may receive good evaluation. 2. Dianne may appreciate Mike's honesty and grant him more time. 3. Alex could be in trouble however the future staff auditors won't be pressured too much and this may help seniors learn more about young staff auditors What are the cons or potential downside of each alternative? Alternative 1. Since Mike ate time, the seniors won't learn their lesson and they'll continue to put pressure on the future staff auditors and the next year budget will only be six hours. 2. Dianne may say the same thing as Alex and Alex will probably get angry at Mike for going around his back to talk to Dianne. Mike may risk his future at the company. 3. Mike may still risk his future at the company or at least get a bad evaluation. Both of those will make his school look bad. What are the implications of "eating time" for Mike, the firm, and others involved? " Mike may come across another ethical challenge and he may become less reasonable in determining his ethical standards. This may also could lead the firm to believe......

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Flattery in Pride and Prejudice | Anthropologie Illusion Monogram Letter | Chăm Sóc Răng Miệng