H J Mccloskey

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By MissBerryMommy
Words 1448
Pages 6
H.J. McCloskey (1968) in his article on being an Atheist aimed to prove atheism a more viable belief than the Christian worldview. McCloskey disputed the three theistic proofs: the cosmological argument, the teleological argument and the argument from design. McCloskey called attention to the presence of evil in a world made by God. He went further saying that it was nonsensical to live by faith. McCloskey contended that proofs were not the reason that people have faith in God but rather people come to rely on religion because of other circumstances in life. In spite of this, the three arguments, show great validity in supporting the God of Christianity’s existence. Examining this from the cumulative case point, there is no for sure argument that supports the existence of God of Christianity but, placing all viewpoints together cumulatively, the case is quite formidable. The Cosmological argument contends that the creator of the universe, the cosmos, is God and God alone. The Teleological Argument expresses an intelligent creator and the argument of morality display how God is an interpersonal, morally flawless God. This supporting information gives some clarity of how the universe was created.
According to McCloskey the Cosmological argument has many flaws because it is only based upon the world as we know it. From McCloskey’s perspective, just because the universe exists, doesn’t necessarily mean that there is a greater being responsible for it. Nor does he think that that an omnipotent being created the world in which he lives. If we examine the Philosophy of Religion, the contingency of the universe backs the declaration that the universe calls for a cause; and God is that cause. (Evans, Manis, 2009) Moreover, the things that we see do not seem to be just things that had to exist, rather they’re contingent and the justification of any contingent beings…...

Similar Documents

Repsonse Paper to Mccloskey

...Response Paper to McCloskey Article “On Being an Atheist”           H.J. McCloskey, claims that “proofs” offered by theists for the existence of God simply do not provide evidence that there is one omnipotent, omniscient being. His arguments about “proofs” question why people are theists, and why theists should abandon their arguments or “proofs”. He claims that most people do not believe in God because of their lack of knowledge about evolution, but in fact most theist believe in God and consider themselves theists, because there is documented evidence that supersedes any “hypothesis” or “theory” that scientists have on the life forms on earth, and even earth itself. “In the beginning, when God created the heavens and the earth.” (Genesis 1:1) Although an atheist may make a convincing argument about there not being a God, and we are all products of evolution, there is no documented, definitive evidence that is fact. Darwin himself even labeled evolution as such, “the theory of evolution.” However, I do believe McCloskey makes a very valid point about the arguments he, as an atheist, is challenging, and he defends his ideas very well. While I can appreciate the theory that it is possible that the universe was a cluster of stars and then one day something exploded and miraculously the galaxies and solar systems were formed and, luckily for us there was one planet that was capable of sustaining life and microscopic organisms and bacteria evolved into all living......

Words: 1684 - Pages: 7

Mej, H, H

...H Com bin e d S t a t e m e n t P a ge 3 of 6 223014054201 Sta temen t P er iod 02-28-12 th r ou gh 03-28-12 B 18 E I E P I 18 0053473 F ARIDAH N ASSE R ALQAH TAN I MyAccess Checking Subtractions A TM an d D ebit Card S u bt ra ct ion s - Con t in u ed F ood Lion #253 03/03 #000427900 P ur chase 1720 E beneezer Ro Rock H ill SC CheckCar d 0302 Ar amar k Wint hr op U niver Rock H ill SC 24755422063120639729378 CheckCar d 0305 U nc Char E lt i Int 704-687-5757 N C 24001752066200247700034 CheckCar d 0305 M cdonald's F 3909 Rock H ill SC 24427332066710025341923 Dollar Tr ee #0 03/07 #000121394 P ur chase 725 Cher r y Rd. Rock H ill SC E ar t h F ar e #25 03/09 #000935134 P ur chase 725 Cher r y Rd Rock H ill NC CheckCar d 0310 Saffr on Indian Cui Gr eenville SC 24224432071104000527001 F ast & F r iendl 03/10 # 000211690 P ur chase 2652 W M ain St Rock H ill SC J . Cr ew F act or 03/10 # 000872411 P u r chase 1 F act or y Shopps Gaffney SC CheckCar d 0310 P olo F act or y St or e #73 Gaffney SC 24610432071004039177947 F ast & F r iendl 03/10 # 000997722 P ur chase 2652 W M ain St Rock H ill SC CheckCar d 0310 P olo F act or y St or e #73 Gaffney SC 24610432071004039177954 Walgr eens 03/15 #000312386 P ur chase 1008 Oakland Ave Rock H ill SC CheckCar d 0313 St ar bucks Cor p00092791 Rock H ill SC 24164072074355321204158 CheckCar d 0314 M assage E nvy 0887 704-3382136 SC 24632692075075133452104 Academy Lt d 03/16 #000011440 P ur chase 2468 Cr oss P oint e Rock H ill SC E xpr...

Words: 566 - Pages: 3

Phil 201 Response Paper Mccloskey Article

...Response Paper Mccloskey Article Clark Hernanser PHIL 201 February 24, 2013 Ramon Graces Response Paper Mccloskey Article In his article, On Being an Atheist, H.J. McCloskey tried to show that atheism is a more reasonable and comfortable belief than that of Christianity.   McCloskey argued against the three theistic proofs, which are the cosmological argument, the teleological argument and the argument from design.   He pointed out the existence of evil in the world that God made.   He also pointed out that it is irrational to live by faith. According to McCloskey, proofs do not necessarily play a vital role in the belief of God.  Page 62 of the article states that "most theists do not come to believe in God as a basis for religious belief, but come to religion as a result of other reasons and factors."  However, he feels that as far as proofs serve theists, the three most commonly accepted are the cosmological, the teleological, and the argument from design.  It is important to note that he considers these arguments as reasons to "move ordinary theists to their theism." (McCloskey 1968) This is not necessary the case and contradicts the former statement that most theists do not hold to these proofs.  As such, the attempt to dispute these arguments as a reason not to believe in God is almost not worth attempting.  If theists do not generally hold to these proofs as reasons for faith, then why bother trying to......

Words: 2073 - Pages: 9

Theistic Response to H.J. Mccloskey

...LIBERTY UNIVERSITY A THEISTIC RESPONSE TO H.J. McCLOSKEY PHIL 201-D10 FALL 2011 DR. EDWARD MARTIN BY IVAN DERRICK COOKE Cooke 2 INTRODUCTION In 1968, atheist philosopher H.J. McCloskey composed a strong argument on how being an atheist was far superior to the theistic lifestyle. This imperious article was published in the journal Question and reflects McCloskey’s view that “atheism is a much more comfortable belief than theism, and why theists should be miserable just because they are theists.”1 In his article, McCloskey seeks to disprove many of the arguments that theists believe and often seemingly ridicules or persecutes those who believe in God. Among the arguments McCloskey attempts to minimalize, there are three common proofs that many, if not all, theists lean on for their belief in God. These proofs include the cosmological proof, the teleological proof, and the argument from design. Furthermore, McCloskey speaks on the problem of evil and how the existence of evil disproves the reality of a God. Near the end of McCloskey’s article, he also insists that atheism is comforting, claiming that it is more comforting than theism. This paper will debate the validity and truth of the three claims that McCloskey seeks to discount in his article and will further debate the problem of evil and disprove the idea that atheism is comforting. PROOFS VS. ARGUMENTS ------------------------------------------------- McCloskey often slights the theistic view as......

Words: 2514 - Pages: 11

Mccloskey

...In The short Story on Being an Atheist, MCcloskey argues that the cosmological proof, the teleological proof and the Ontological argument should be abandoned because they do not established with any degree of certainty, that God does exist. The cosmological argument is used to prove the existence of a necessary or eternal Creator. Philosophers argue that because the universe exists, some God like being had to cause it to come into existence. It was established that everything that exist had to have a beginning that caused them to exist, and in their opinion that cause was God who is outside of the universe. The Teleological arguments are arguments from the order in the universe to the existence of God. They are also known as arguments to design. These arguments purport to prove the existence of God from empirical facts, the premise being that the universe shows evidence of order and hence design. The Ontological arguments is a priori argument for the existence of God, asserting that as existence is a perfection, and as God is conceived of as the most perfect being, then God must exist. With MCcloskey or any atheist they offer no evidence on how the universe came into existence scientifically or otherwise. On the Cosmological Argument MCcloskey says that the “mere existence of the world constitutes no reason for believing in such a being.” But according to Evans and Manis the cause of the universe is necessary because any explanation of any contingent being’s......

Words: 324 - Pages: 2

J&J Johnson and Johnson

...the product which she gives to her baby, you have to trust the medicine you take, when it comes to health care people have to trust and with buying the J&J products people give Johnson & Johnson something back. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlTijmelPCQ) What to do in the Future The company has simply to adapt to the new market situations. People get older and chronicle health disorders are becoming more frequent. J &J has to fulfil these needs if they want to stay on top of the league. Sometimes it is useful to make partnerships or new collaborations to be innovative. It will become vital to recognise and explore new markets. For example the Asian market is booming right now and more people are in the middle class and with the money the striving for better health care increases. J&J has to be one of the first who fulfils this needs and earns the trust of these people. It is also important to get the attention of these people in the new markets therefore you have to adapt the product on the market environments. For example J&J launched Listerine Green Tea for the Asian market. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwCWSRxg3hA) List of literature Jamal Shamsie, 2007, Johnson & Johnson Renata Jennings, 2013, Copy of SWOT Analysis: Johnson & Johnson Leslie P. Norton, 2013, Embracing the J&J credo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlTijmelPCQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwCWSRxg3hA http://marketingteacher.com/...

Words: 966 - Pages: 4

H. J. Heinz: Estimating the Cost of Capital in Uncertain Times

...UV5147 Rev. Nov. 15, 2013 H. J. HEINZ: ESTIMATING THE COST OF CAPITAL IN UNCERTAIN TIMES To do a common thing uncommonly well brings success. —H. J. Heinz Founder Henry John Heinz As a financial analyst at the H. J. Heinz Company (Heinz) in its North American Consumer Products division, Solomon Sheppard, together with his co-workers, reviewed investment proposals involving a wide range of food products. Most discussions in his office focused on the potential performance of new products and reasonableness of cash flow projections. But as the company finished its 2010 fiscal year at the end of April—with financial markets still in turmoil from the onset of the recession that started at the end of 2007—the central topic of discussion was the company’s weighted average cost of capital (WACC). At the time, there were three reasons the cost of capital was a subject of controversy. First, Heinz’s stock price had just finished a two-year roller coaster ride: Its fiscal year-end stock price dropped from $47 in 2008 to $34 in 2009, then rose back to $47 in 2010, and a vigorous debate ensued as to whether the weights in a cost of capital calculation should be updated to reflect these changes as they occurred. Second, interest rates remained quite low—unusually so for longer-term bond rates; there was concern that updating the cost of capital to reflect these new rates would lower the cost of capital and therefore bias in favor of accepting projects. Third, there was a strong sense...

Words: 2741 - Pages: 11

Response Paper to Mccloskey

...Response Paper McCloskey Article Liberty University Philosophy 201 Fall 2013 H.J. McCloskey (1968) in his article on being an Atheist aimed to prove atheism a more viable belief than the Christian worldview. McCloskey disputed the three theistic proofs: the cosmological argument, the teleological argument and the argument from design. McCloskey called attention to the presence of evil in a world made by God. He went further saying that it was nonsensical to live by faith. McCloskey contended that proofs were not the reason that people have faith in God but rather people come to rely on religion because of other circumstances in life. In spite of this, the three arguments, show great validity in supporting the God of Christianity’s existence. Examining this from the cumulative case point, there is no for sure argument that supports the existence of God of Christianity but, placing all viewpoints together cumulatively, the case is quite formidable. The Cosmological argument contends that the creator of the universe, the cosmos, is God and God alone. The Teleological Argument expresses an intelligent creator and the argument of morality display how God is an interpersonal, morally flawless God. This supporting information gives some clarity of how the universe was created. According to McCloskey the Cosmological argument has many flaws because it is only based upon the world as we know it. From McCloskey’s perspective, just because the universe exists, doesn’t......

Words: 1458 - Pages: 6

S H J M S

...Sacred Heart of Jesus Montessori School Highschool Department - Recto Campus Cagayan De Oro City Name: Arrah-Lou D. Palma Date Submitted: Oct. 24, 2014 Section: Gentleness Teacher: Shareen Baslot 1. Summarize Mark Twain’s significant points In The Damned Human Race, Mark Twain compares the behavior of different animals to human beings to prove in contrary to the Darwinian Theory. Humans actually descended from higher beings. His essay proves a lot of good points. Humans are selfish and wasteful, while animals take only what they need to survive, humans are the only beings in nature that hold grudges and take revenge and that humans are the only beings with morals. I agree and disagree with Mark Twain’s essay. He did live in a different time but cruelty still exists the same. If you analyze the human race or all animals, you can find evil in both creatures. Humans and animals cannot be compared properly. Animals do some awful things to each other as well as human. Mark Twain just lists human’s bad traits. There are a lot of positive traits of humans; he goes into detail of only the negative traits of humans. If there are bad people, there can also be good people. It’s true today, and was also true in the time Mark Twain lived in. In the 1860s, around the time when Mark Twain lived, there was an American Civil War and this is probably why he was so ashamed of human beings. There is something he......

Words: 933 - Pages: 4

J&J Amp

...To: Date: December 2 At the meeting last week, J&J was considering how it should account for the Shiny Teeth coupon drop that took place on October 1, 2012. As discussed of your concerns, we conducted our audit in accordance with auditing standards general accepted in the United States of America. My responsibility is to express an opinion on our findings of the audit. I believe that our audit provides a reasonable basis for our opinion. Our focus was on the Shiny Teeth coupon drop. The accounting issue is determining redemption rate offered on September 1 and drop on October 1, 2012. According to FASB Accounting Standards Codification 605-50-05-1a a vendor's accounting for consideration given by a vendor to a customer (including both a reseller of the vendor’s products and an entity that purchases the vendor’s products from a reseller). Such consideration (including sales incentives) offered by a vendor on either a limited or a continuous basis to a customer may take various forms including discounts, coupons, rebates, and free products or services. The accounting issue is the correct recognition of coupons offered on the sale of toothpaste. We will address the issue of timing and measurement of the revenues and liabilities resulting from the coupon. Next, we looked at the effect of the Shiny Teeth coupon drop on its financial and how it should be recognized. The sale incentive (coupon) offered by the company and retailer reduced the price of the......

Words: 971 - Pages: 4

J&J Memo

...long-lived assets and implications associated with Johnson and Johnson’s accounting methods.  In this memo we would like to cover five main topics: long-lived assets, depreciation and amortization, J&J policies regarding intangible assets, cash flow statements, and asset turnover/ return on assets. In 2013, J&J reported three different types of long-lived assets on their Consolidated Balance Sheet. The first kind reported was Plant, Property, and Equipment. The second one was Intangible Assets and third was Goodwill. We will be investigating these three assets in further detail.  J&J reported $16,710 million net worth of PP&E. Within this major asset category are many sub accounts: Land & Improvements, Building & Building Equipment, and Construction in Progress, Machine & Equipment, and Depreciation.  Johnson & Johnson uses the straight-line depreciation method for its assets.  In 2013, there was $2.7 billion of accumulated depreciation and amortization of capitalized interested; it increased about $.2 billion since 2012. Table 1 lays out the estimated useful lives of the assets. The company capitalizes certain computer software and development cost which are amortized over the span of 3-8 years. Next, we will be discussing Intangible Assets of the company. J&J reports $1,363 million worth of amortization expense. In 2012, they reported about $1,146 million.  The average amortization periods for patents and trademarks and customer......

Words: 937 - Pages: 4

Mccloskey Responses

...sponse Response Paper Stephanie Brockman PHIL 201 McCloskey Responses Introduction H. J. McCloskey gets most of his strong statements against the belief by asking the atheist to provide sufficient proof that God exists. However, McCloskey is not the only person who is unsure and asks questions God’s existence based on personal beliefs or influence. From the beginning many people have had questions about God and his existence. He wrote numerous books on atheism between 1960 and 1980 including the famous book, God and Evil. This paper evaluates the credibility of McCloskey’s article “On being an Atheist”. One of the McCloskey’s core arguments against theism is his demand for any proof that ascertains theists’ beliefs on God’s existence. He believed that atheism is more comforting than theism because most Christians do not believe in God because of proof but because of certain reasons and factors, he is looking for more solid evidence in God’s existence. However, there are several reasons why a person should believe in the existence of God. Firstly, theists believe that God is the creator of all things and of nature. Therefore, God is the creator of all things in existence and that affect both the atheists and theists are affected by this. The Bible also states, that Koran and other religious literatures all communicate the existence of a high power with some similar characteristics. These writings have been in existence for several years without any alteration of......

Words: 1660 - Pages: 7

J&J Analysis

...Summers Daniel Vijayakumar SUMMARY Johnson & Johnson (“J&J”), one of the largest, well-known organizations in the world, produces products for consumer health care and for use by medical professionals in care and diagnostics. Some of their most recognizable brands include Tylenol, Neutrogena, Listerine, Band-Aid and Reactine. These, along with their many other brands, are produced in over 60 countries by more than 250 different operating companies that make up the J&J organization. In total, more than 114,000 employees are part of the organization, and they are managed through a system of decentralized management with a wide span of control. J&J faces the unique challenge of trying to create one corporate culture that all parts of their organization believe in and adhere to. One of the strategies used to combat these obstacles is values-based leadership and linking employees and subsidiaries under a common set of values, as outlined in "Our Credo". J&J works extremely hard to uphold their Credo, which was written by Robert Wood Johnson – one of the founders of the organization – in 1943. It is a set of values that J&J vow to work by and which lend to the present culture that is so important in the organization today. J&J also attempts to induce a culture of innovation and promote diversity and acceptance of differences throughout its subsidiaries. Since organizational culture is such a vital piece in connecting J&J’s subsidiaries, a very strong culture has developed. In......

Words: 5893 - Pages: 24

Response Paper to Mccloskey Article

...Elder 1 Tonisha Elder Phil 201 Response to McCloskey article May 7, 2016 Elder 2 In McCloskey’s article “On Being an Atheist”, McCloskey shares with us his arguments on why being an atheist is more comforting (if you will) than being a Christian. McCloskey believes that the three proofs (Cosmological, Teleological, and the argument from design) are not a basis for proving God’s existence. McCloskey discharges the proofs by saying in his article, “, theists do not come to believe in God as a result of reflecting on the proofs, but come to religion as a result of other reasons and factors.” (McCloskey, 62). Although there are many ways that one could come to believe in Gods existence, thinking cosmologically, I can’t help but to look at Gods splendor around me or think of the universe, and doubt that God does in fact exist. In “Approaching the Question of God’s existence, Foreman says, “There are certain effects we see in the universe that show God exists.” (Foreman). Foreman touches on the fact that there is no one argument that proves one hundred percent that God exists. He goes on to share that these three arguments do have value, and when put altogether they all do prove to some degree that God does in fact exist. McCloskey attempts to break down each of the proofs to in a way persuade the reader on why these proofs are invalid. The first one he addresses is the cosmological argument. This proof or argument is the one that is most argued...

Words: 1827 - Pages: 8

J and J

...model for social responsibility. Moreover, the company is clearly prepared for the many challenges its ever-changing international business environment poses. Due to its strategic positioning and eye on the future, Johnson & Johnson will likely survive another century. REFERENCES Academic Visit to Johnson & Johnson, Prague, Czech Republic. “2008 Annual Report.” Johnson & Johnson Gassman, Oliver, Gerrit Reepmeyer and Maximilian von Zedtwitz. “Leading Pharmaceutical Innovation.” Springer “The Global Pharmaceutical Industry.” Duke University “Mental health drug market tapped out?” CNNMoney.com “Our Credo Values.” Johnson & Johnson. “Patent Expirations Behind J&J Cuts, C&T Looks Closer at Patents.” Cosmetics and Toiletries “Porter's Five Forces: A Model For Industry Analysis.” QuickMBA “A Recent History Of The Pharmaceutical Industry.” Venture Navigator...

Words: 4303 - Pages: 18

OAV 001 vostfr | Watch Movie | Vedi Prodotto