Free Essay

Our Aromatic Uncle

In: Novels

Submitted By jpariseau
Words 1258
Pages 6
The Victorian society of the nineteenth-century was a period marked by sensationalism and superficiality but also by the emergence of a new kind of novel and short story that expressed ideas about subjects that were normally taboo or avoided in this society. A year before his death in 1896, Henry Cuyler Bunner wrote the short story “Our Aromatic Uncle” which presents an unreliable narrator and very strong allusions to same-sex love . This essay will analyze the homosexual subtext in Bunner’s short story. This text will explore how the phrase popularized by Oscar Wild “the love that dares not speak its name” express itself as well as on what and how same-sex love is displaced in the short story. To analyze the homosexual subtext, this essay will also examine what discrepancies can be observed in Bunner’s story and how they lead the reader to question the reliability of the narrator. First of all, the short story, written by Bunner in 1895, presents the story of a judge’s son and a butcher-boy who leave the United States to go to China. The only contact David, the judge’s son, has had with his family is short and brief letters that he sent few times per year along with some gifts that had all a particular aroma prior to his death. However, further in the story we can realize that the letters as well as the gifts have not been sent by David but by the butcher-boy, Tommy Biggs. This aspect brings the reader to some interrogations regarding the actual relation between David and Tommy. We can read in Bunner’s story that “the butcher-boy worshipped him with the deepest and most fervent adoration” (203). By this statement, made by the narrator, we can understand that the feelings of Tommy Biggs toward David have been a lot more that comradeship or even strong friendship. The use of the words “adoration” and “admiration” probably suggests a very strong feeling of love from the little butcher-boy toward the judge’s son (Bunner 203). Another really good example that Tommy really put David on a pedestal occurs when the narrator mentions “to the butcher-boy it did not seem right in the nature of things that anything should displease the judge’s son” (204). We can conclude that Tommy has not the kind behavior somebody usually has with a person who is a friend or even a best friend. This admiration and adoration is a kind of behavior that we sometime see when one person in a couple is in complete admiration with his beloved one. Finally, we can certainly agree that Bunner illustrated, in "Our Aromatic Uncle", the love of a man for another but he definitely portrayed it indirectly since same-sex love between two individuals was taboo and not socially accepted in Victorian society. Second of all, this story written at the end of the nineteenth-century can be summarized in one very short sentence popularized by Oscar Wilde. Wilde used and popularized the short phrase “the love that dares not speak its name”. It is totally obvious that this statement talks about homosexuality and same-sex love at a time where it was unconventional and not generally accepted by the society. It also expresses the feelings of shame and guiltiness homosexual people can had in Victorian society and even nowadays. This popular sentence can easily be linked to the short story written by Bunner because there is, in “Our Aromatic Uncle”, very strong allusions to homosexuality without ever using this kind of term to describe the relation between Tommy and David. It is really interesting to see how the author successfully carries to the reader this perception of same-sex love without using the exact name of this “strange” relation. Some other clues in the story let also the reader believe that Tommy has never officially declared his love to David. We can read at the end of Bunner’s story that the little butcher-boy “ran away to sea to be body-guard, servant and friend to the splendid, showy, selfish youth [David] whom he worshipped; whose heartlessness he cloaked for many a long year, who lived upon his bounty, and who died in his arms, nursed with a tenderness surpassing that of a brother” (212). This description definitely shows that the unconditional love of Tommy for David has never been expressed loud and clear and this can, without a doubt, be related to “the love that dares not speak its name”. To conclude, some passages also let the reader believe that David had probably not the same kind of feeling for Tommy. The old gentleman explains to the narrator that David had no money, that he drank a lot and that he had relations with ladies (211). Third of all, as same-sex love is not clearly expressed in the text, we can definitely argue that Bunner displaces the various clear terms about homosexuality on admiration and adoration. The fact that this story was written during the Victorian period might have played a major role in this displacement. By displacing same-sex love on adoration and admiration without truly mentioning homosexuality, Bunner leaves the reader with the choice of how the story should be interpreted. Bunner was then able to write about a subject that was taboo at that time. Depending on the interpretation of the reader, another demonstration of the same-sex love and its displacement in this short story might be the fact that Tommy write and send gift to David’s family to be sure that his family is proud and admires him almost as much as Tommy adores him. Another aspect that the author uses to suggest that things are not what they seem is the actual position of Uncle David in the family. The narrator always refers to him as an uncle and Tommy refers to the narrator and his wife as nephew and niece. However, the wife’s father is the judge and the judge is also David’s father. The narrator even contradicts himself when he explains that the judge’s son, his wife’s uncle, ran away to sea (Bunner 204). Moreover, the “certain Aunt Lucretia” is described as being the sister of the “Aromatic Uncle” (Bunner 208). There is, at that point, a really important discrepancy in the family structure which leads the reader to question if the narrator is reliable or not. In fact, if Aunt Lucretia and Uncle David are brother and sister and they have the same parents as the narrator’s wife, then they are all brothers and sisters. We can then conclude that the narrator is not reliable and that everything in Bunner’s short story is almost certainly not as it seems.

Finally, Henry Cuyler Bunner successfully wrote, with “Our Aromatic Uncle”, a short story about same-sex love between two individuals at a time when homosexuality was not socially accepted in the society and was considered as a taboo subject. By writing a story full of allusions, displacements and contradictions, Bunner is able to carry his message to the reader by offering them a short story that is free to interpretation and which does not directly go beyond Victorian conventions. It is definitely through interpretation of the story that Bunner cleverly brings his readers one step further and make them cross the social norms of the nineteenth-century.

References
Bunner, Henry Cuyler. "Our Aromatic Uncle." Glances Backward: An Anthology of American Homosexual Writing, 1830-1920. Ed. James Gifford. Ontario, Canada: Broadview Press, 2007. 202-212. Print.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Uncle Tom's Cabin

...to Eliza, he was whipped him. Eliza, his wife, is telling him to be patient and just to believe in God. George Harris has no plan of staying anymore at his master’s house so he plans on escaping to Canada, and wait until he can pay for the freedom of his son and wife. I really like the chareacteristic here of Eliza, she really believes in God, and even telling her husband to believe also. She supports her husband in all the thing she does. The main lesson in this story is just to believe and trust in God. Like what Eliza had advised his husband to never lose faith in God because he always know what is best for us. The main theme on this chapter, is about religion. It is mostly about having faith in God. Chapter 4 : In this chapter, Uncle Tom’s cabin was described and he was living there with Aunt Chloe which is also a servant of the Shelby’s. She was the head cook and she cooks very well. Her pie crust is also sometimes being described like a female body. While they were having a ceremony with the other servants, Mr. Haley and Mr. Shelby talked and came to the plan that Tom will be sold to Mr. Haley, Mr. Shelby asked Mr. Haley to put Tom in good hands and with a good master, and Mr. Haley answered that he will try but he will not promise. In this chapter, we saw again the cruelty of Mr. Haley, he really wants to get Tom not bothering if he will leave someone while the main theme on this chapter is love. We saw how Mr. Shelby loves Tom, it was against his will to sell Tom...

Words: 8111 - Pages: 33

Free Essay

Uncle Bob

...exciting on the horizon that someone is talking about. The last place that you would think you would have a negative experience with technology is on vacation; trying to enjoy the sun atmosphere of a place other than home. This is exactly what happened to my Uncle Bob; he was stopped for speeding in Florida. He answered the Law Enforcement Officers’ questions calmly and was then placed into the back of his cruiser. The process by which the Officer obtained the information is very routine; personal, one-on-one conversation. Many people do not realize it but when they are talking to an officer of the law, that person is constantly being evaluated; verbal and non-verbal. The officer is always taking in information no matter now simple is may seem. While Uncle Bob was being questioned he provided the following: his name, birth date, height, and weight, and resident state. As this is the basic form of information gathering the officer then would have entered the information gathered into their regional type database. Once the officer relayed the specific data to the regional office or agency the bigger wheels started to turn. This would have been completed either via radio and the distant end using a searchable database to input Uncle Bob’s information or the officer might have had the means to affect this himself. Newer police cruisers have computers connected to the main regional office so the officer in the field can provide quicker customer service to the community. Once......

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Effect of Uncle Tom's Cabin

...Seldom does a one work of literature change a society or start it down the road to cataclysmic conflict. One such catalytic work is Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852). It is considered by many, one the most influential American works of fiction ever published. Uncle Tom's Cabin sold more copies than any other previous fiction title. It sold five thousand copies in its first two days, fifty thousand copies in eight weeks, three hundred thousand copies in a year and over a million copies in its first sixteen months. What makes this accomplishment even more amazing is that this book was written by a woman during a time in history women were relegated to domestic duties and child rearing and were not allowed positions of influence or leadership roles in society. Legend holds that when Abraham Lincoln met Stowe in 1682 he said, "So you're the little woman who wrote the book that made this great war". The impact of Uncle Tom's Cabin did more to arouse antislavery sentiment in the N orth and provoke angry rebuttals in the south than any other event in antebellum era. Harriet Beecher Stowe (1811-1896), born Lichfeild, Connecticut, was the daughter, sister, and wife of liberal clergymen and theologians. Her father Lyman and brother Henry Ward were two of the most preeminent theologians of the nineteenth century. This extremely devout Christian upbringing, focusing on the......

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Uncle

...in China. That day we met, but I was too sick from the never-ending flight to express the joy. It was my uncle who had opened the doors for us: my parents, siblings, and me, to come to Mei Gok (Chinese for America). It was he, who worked for our opportunities, cooking in a restaurant during the day and studying at night to pass the ever-so-important naturalization test. While he had less than three years of education, he was indeed the most intelligent and perfect man whom I aspire to be like. The father of two and husband of the worst of wives, he strove for the best future for his two young children. He sent them to Catholic school, filled the house with more than enough of their favorite foods, made the warmest of homes, and was always there to support them in any way. His only hobby and outlet was music. On Sundays, his day off, after his trip with my cousin to Chinatown, he often sat with his family or played with one of his seven instruments. I still remember the afternoons when I listened to him playing along to his favorite Chinese opera and the nights I waited for him to return from work. He passed away, but the memories will forever live within me. He always encouraged me to work hard for what I deserve. Being a witness of his undying spirit, I've taken him as my idol, because he is greater than any super hero, athlete, or scientist. He was my uncle, a proud man who made the most of his life and certainly did all he could in his power for others. -...

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Uncle Joe

...Uncle Joe A unique sense of humor, an intimidating softie, and one of the most caring guys I know. These are just a few traits that make my uncle Joe different from all the rest. When it comes to his sense of humor, I think of the ledge and the bear outside our car. When it comes to his appearance, you never see anyone else who looks like him; when you see him once, you never forget what he looks like. When it comes to his appearance, you would never think of his personality to be so caring. He is one of the greatest guys on the world and if you got to know him like I know him you would think the same thing. When it comes to Uncle Joe’s sense of humor, there is nothing that can match it. When he does something funny, he will always put a little smirk on his face and try not to smile and act like he is the cleverest guy in the world. When I was little, he would always take me to ‘the ledge’. This was a ledge over the dam in Sauk Prairie where he used to live. When he took me to this ledge he would sit me down and have my feet dangle over the edge. He would always act like he couldn’t hold on to me and I thought I was going to fall of the ledge. I would cry my eyes out and he would think it was just the funniest thing ever. Another torturous act my uncle Joe did to me when I was little was the bear outside the car. We would be driving along in the woods and he would drive real slow and ask me if I saw the bear outside. At the time I was scared of bears so my eyes......

Words: 754 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Uncle Tom

...|设计地点 |第二教学楼 | Acknowledgements Many people gave me support and help in the process of writing the paper. I’d like first to give my grate to my dear teacher, Andy, who generously gave me his kindly help and instructions during the whole process of my paper-writing. Then I’d like to give my many thanks to my classmates who helped me a lot with my information collecting and paper-polishing. Most important of all, I want to give my thanks to my mother university and all the teachers in the English Department, who educated and cultivated me to be a qualified graduate in the future. Abstract When Harriet Beecher Stowe published Uncle Tom’s Cabin in 1852, the novel was a huge success. It talked about the slavery which was a controversial issue at that time. Many critics made comments on this novel. With the passage of time, attitudes to the book changed considerably. The history of African American in US has always been considered as a bitter story. In recent years, their status has been improved greatly. In 2008, Barack Obama was elected President, the first African American President in history. Have political and historical events exerted a subtle influence on people’s perceptions of novel? The thesis will mainly focus on various comments by writers and famous people in different times. The perspective object is to see the changing attitude towards the novel. In......

Words: 5443 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Uncle Ernest Summary

...Uncle Ernest is about an old war veteran and a self-employed upholsterer called Ernest Brown. Ernest Brown is described as a very lonely man and untidy. His friends lost their lives in the war and therefore Ernest has had to adapt to loneliness. Ernest has a café that he visits each and every day. One day, two young girls come into the Café. The youngest sits down while the older goes to the counter where Ernest is standing. Ernest returns to his table to find the young girl sitting there. Confused and shy he sits down and proceeds to eat his food. The older one returns to the table, sits down and starts talking with her younger sister, completely oblivious of Ernest. One thing leads to another and Ernest ends up talking to the girls. The girls only have their mother to support them, so they rarely get to see her because she works all the time to pay the bills. Ernest offers to buy them food each and every day and is happy that he finally has someone in his life. He buys them food and it escalates into him buying them presents as well. The girls gladly take the food and presents and they begin calling him “Uncle Ernest”. The older girl begins to try and take advantage of Ernest and asks for more and more. One day, Ernest is confronted by two detectives. They tell him to leave the girls alone and say they know all about him and his history of apparently being a little too generous and interested in young children. The young girls were never harmed and for a while, they didn’t......

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Summary of Uncle Tom's Cabin

...that if the time comes, he will buy Eliza and their son so that they can all be together. At Uncle Tom’s cabin, Aunt Chloe, the cook, and Master George, Mr. Shelby’s son, discuss things about cooking, pies, and even about Jinny, another cook from Tom Lincoln’s. Master George was teaching Uncle Tom how to write the letter ‘g’. After a while, the people were coming to the place to celebrate and sing along with the others. On one of the tables, however, Mr. Shelby and Haley came to a settlement where Mr. Shelby signed papers regarding the deal. Mr. Shelby clarified to Haley that he should never sell Tom and Haley agreed. Still, Mr. Shelby was not convinced in Haley’s expression. Later that night, Mrs. Shelby inquires to his husband about the man he was with. Mr. Shelby reveals that the man’s name was ‘Haley’, a trader whom he had been accountable for. He then told her that he has decided to trade Tom and Harry in order to settle his debts to Haley. Mrs. Shelby becomes angry for entering into a deal like that. She tells him that maybe her gold watch can at least save Eliza’s son but Mr. Shelby replies that the papers have been signed. Mr. Shelby tells her wife that the exchange will happen in the next day. Meanwhile, Eliza heard every single word exchanged by her masters. She immediately packed up her things and her son’s. As they left, they passed by Uncle Tom’s cabin. Aunt Chloe and Uncle Tom saw Eliza running away with her child and with Old Bruno, the dog. Eliza informs......

Words: 1910 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Our Sercets

...and having others inspire someone can only have positive effects on them. As a child one finds a person in their life to look up to and motivate them to do great things. Our Secrets by Susan Griffin tells how people in her past make her the way she is today. Many people in my live inspire me to do great things and live up to the potential I have. So many people in my live inspired me and continue to do so as I mature into adulthood. My dance teacher, grandmother, uncle, and mom all inspire me as a young child and they things they said and did are now put in to action as I see myself becoming an adult and on my own. Throughout “Our Secret” Griffin explores the different characters’ fears and secrets and she gives specific insights into these “secrets”. Through examining others Griffin comes to terms with her own feelings, secrets, and fears. Susan Griffin states, “Now, for different reasons, I too find myself on the track of a child’s soul. The dimensions of Heinrich Himmler’s life have put me on this track.’” (239). This saying the book leads me to think that Himmler shaped her and made her who she is today. My life is shaped around people who motivate to be successful. My family and friends are the ones who lead me to where I am today. Going to college was not an option it was necessary. My dance teacher, my uncle, grandmother, and mother installed the wisdom I have today. My family is very important to me; they have encouraged me through good times and supported me through......

Words: 940 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Uncle Terry

...Uncle Terry Paula Hebb ENG121 Jennifer Miller May 4, 2015 Uncle Terry When my mom died, I wasn't aware that she had siblings. The only person I had met in my mother's family was my grandmother. After my mom's funeral, we lost touch, and I didn't give her any more thought. That was until I read my mom's obituary in May 2014. The obituary said that my mom was survived by a brother, whose name was Terry Cartwright. I thought it might be a long shot, and I didn't have anything to loose, so I decided to search for him. I went online, and there were several Terry Cartwright's listed in Ohio. I knew that I would be traveling to Michigan soon, so I decided to make a side trip to visit my mom's grave in Ohio and find a little piece of my mom and her extended family. I was ecstatic to have this connection to my mom. I traveled to Michigan to visit my cousin Deb. I stayed with her for a couple of days and then I left to go to Warren, Ohio. My mom is buried there, and I thought maybe the burial records would give me an address to my grandmother if she were still alive. I arrived in Warren, and since it was so late I checked into my hotel, then decided to wait until morning to go to the cemetery. I woke up excited the next day because I was one step closer to meeting my uncle. I showered, dressed and left to the cemetery. When I stopped by the office and spoke with the office manager. I asked her if there was a way to find out who was responsible for my mother's grave site.......

Words: 1002 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Uncle Jim

...Dear Uncle Jim, Another great day here in Erie, PA over a foot of snow…wishing I was down South right now or Down in Dallas to be at the Ohio State game on Monday. Although our class today was 5 hours, it went by surprisingly quick and we did a lot of useful activities. I’m a finance major and going back over excel is great because I’m a little rusty with it. Excel is going to be a part of me for the rest of my life so it’s always good going over it again. Today we did group projects on the whole population of the world and we did coordinates of Vermont which was very fun. We went over the latitudes and longitudes which was a good review because I haven’t taken a science class in a while so it’s always good to review things. We then learned what contour lines are. They connect the same level of elevations in a region such as Vermont. In our lab we had to connect the contours in that area. Vermont is an area of a lot of mountains so there are a lot of high elevations. It was very interesting connecting the contours of this region and I can’t wait to finish that project. We had to calculate all of the latitudes and longitudes of the areas and it was another chance to use excel to calculate those. Overall it was another great day here besides the weather. I’m enjoying my time back here with my friends, but I always love being home with my friends there. I was going to go home this weekend to go to the Ohio State vs. Penn State wrestling match on Sunday, but the weather is......

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Uncle Tom's Cabin

...elderly as much as they could. Though everyone struggled, being an enslaved child could have possibly been the worst age to be during this time. Most slave children were torn from their blood families which created a lack of love and affection which every child should have in their younger years of life. Thus, these children were forced into their slave owners homes which created a new family for them, sometimes positive or negative. Most importantly, slave children weren’t given much of a childhood; they were torn from their human rights of freedom, education, equality, and many other civil liberties. Uncle Tom’s Cabin, a fictional work by Harriet Beecher Stowe, accurately compares to the real accounts of former slaves on the subject of enslaved children. Along with Stowe’s book, many slave narratives talk about these unfortunate events enslaved children went through. In Uncle Tom’s Cabin, Harry is the first child Stowe introduces to the reader. Even though his story ends up having a happy ending, his family had always been incomplete while they were enslaved. Harry is Eliza and Henry Harris’s son; due to Eliza and Henry being on different farms, Harry would rarely ever see his father. Therefore, Harry and his father could not engage in many bonding experiences white children and their fathers could enjoy. In chapter III, Mr. Harris escapes to Canada because his master is forcing him to marry another woman on his own farm, ultimately, having to abandon Eliza and Harry.......

Words: 1658 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Uncle Tom's Cabin

...Uncle Tom’s Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe is a unique historical fiction novel which portrays life during the American Civil War. In this story, Harriet Beecher Stowe tells the tale of Uncle Tom, along with several other slaves, and their journey through the wretchedness of slavery. She combines ethics, redemption, religion, and prejudice; and illuminates the hard truths about the sordid business by having characters alleviate or minimize guilt by comparing themselves to slave owners who treat their slaves far worse than they do. Slave owners vary from Mr. Shelby to Augustine St. Clair to Marie St. Clair to Simon Legree. Slave owners like Shelby and St. Clair imagine themselves as moral owners by treating their slaves in a kind, humane and benevolent way that avoids cruelty like flogging. Despite all the arguments used to justify and rationalize slavery, Stowe mounts great evidence to prove the injustice, cruelty, and evil truths of slavery. Having run up large debts, a Kentucky farmer named Arthur Shelby faces the prospect of losing everything he owns. Though he and his wife, Emily Shelby, have a kindhearted and affectionate relationship with their slaves, Shelby decides to raise money by selling two of his slaves to Mr. Haley, a coarse slave trader. Mr. and Mrs. Shelby value their slaves as faithful employees who deserve respect, civility, and kindness. However, Mr. Shelby views slavery primarily as a business and fails to realize that he is splitting up Tom’s family...

Words: 628 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Analysis of Serebryakov in Uncle Vanya

...the years, they looked after the Estate and contributed to the wellbeing of the Professor for nothing. Uncle Vayna said it perfectly “For twenty-five years I have managed this place, and have sent you the returns from it like the most honest of servants, and you have never given me one single word of thanks for my work, not one--neither in my youth nor now”. He feels used and unappreciated for what he has done for him. But the ultimate demonstration of selfishness is when the Professor tells everyone that he decides to sell the estate so that he can write a paper to make money and hopefully buy a villa in Finland for him and Elena. In this proposition, there was no mention of his daughter, or Vanya. It was because of Vanya and Sonya that such an option was possible in the first place. For someone of that age, I wonder how he can be so selfish. There is not much left for him in his life and he wants to buy a villa for himself? Meanwhile, Sonya and Vanya are living hopeless lives with potentially no place to live if the estate is indeed sold. In addition, the estate is not the Professor’s to sell to begin with! Vanya ridicules the Professor in the following quote “I have never had a grain of sense in my head. I have always been stupid enough to think that the estate belonged to Sonia. My father bought it as a wedding present for my sister, and I foolishly imagined that as our laws were made for Russians and not Turks, my sister's estate would come down to her child.” The......

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Bobs Your Uncle

...in the vast sea of nutrition information that is on our internet, in textbooks and in other "expert" nutrition reports. So, right here, right now, we're going to explain it all to you in this easy to understand, yet scientifically-supported, special report. When you're done reading this report, you'll finally be told what you should eat and when you should eat it after your next workout so you can start your new journey for a better, happier and healthier body. But, enough of the fluff, let's get started. Table of Contents Exercise Metabolism and Physiology.... The Cliff's Notes version (or, What happens in your body when you're working out) Post-Exercise Metabolism(or, What happens in your body in the postworkout window) Bad food, bad body - What happens in your body when you make bad food choices after your workout Good food, great body - What happens in your body when you make good food choices after your workout Quick Review & Action Plan 4 22 30 34 37 What Happens in Your Body When You're Working Out To really understand what happens in your body when you're working out, we have to pull information from the sciences of nutrition, exercise biochemistry, biology and physiology. But, if we did that in the depths that it could be covered, you might run away screaming with the fear of scary scientific equations and terminology. Heck, even we groan when we have to start talking about this stuff because it makes our minds feel a bit overworked. So, we're not going......

Words: 8920 - Pages: 36

Baixar toque para celular | Adventure | Porsche Carrera 4S (997)