Rebuttal: Empty Promise of Embryonic Stem Cell Research

In: Business and Management

Submitted By maurenito
Words 669
Pages 3
Rebuttal: Empty Promise of Embryonic Stem Cell Research
Maurice Gooden
BCOM 275
April 24, 2012
Todd Brenton

Rebuttal to Embryonic stem cell research

There has been much debate over the controversial topic of embryonic stem cell research as it pertains to its morality. Many supporters of pro-life and various religious followers compare this research to murder because of their belief that human life starts from conception. On the other hand, scientists and researchers want to use these cultures of cells and make good use of this science for the greater advancement in modern medicine. It is hard to sway either ideology because there is no hard written documentation that outlines the contingency of this concept.

There are many opinionated articles that touch on this subject and its morality. Prime example comes from an article written by Mike Pence in the Christianity Times. Throughout much of this article, there is use of subtle scare tactic, and rationalizing. He states, “Millions of pro-life Americans believe that life is sacred, and I along with them was deeply troubled by President Obama's executive order eliminating restrictions on embryonic stem-cell research not only because it destroys human life, but particularly because it ignores the advances that have been made in adult stem-cell research.” (Pence, 2009). He is leading us to believe that this step toward medical science will be worthless, and in the process destroying potential life from these embryos. However, “Consensus among researchers has been that adult stem cells are limited in usefulness because they can be used to produce only a few of the 220 types of cells found in the human body.” (White). “Embryonic stem cells are blank cells that have not yet been categorized or programmed by the body, and can be prompted to generate any of the 220 human cell types. Embryonic stem cells are…...

Similar Documents

Embryonic Stem Cell Research

...Embryonic Stem Cell Research Embryonic stem cell research has been a topic that has been debated for some time but the benefits of stem cells deserves a second look. Many may be unsure about how research is performed with the stem cells and how we acquire the embryonic stem cells. I believe that after providing some educational information on this, there may be a change in opinion on this First, we need to understand what a stem cell is. A stem cell is a cell that divides via mitosis and then changes into a specialized cell. They can be found in bone marrow, adipose tissue, blood and the umbilical cord. These cells can self-renew to produce more stem cells. From the stem cell, there are stem cell lines. This is a group of cells that descend from one original cell. Cells in a stem cell line are free of genetic defects and create more stem cells. From the cell lines, a cluster can be removed. Researchers can freeze the cells for storage or share with other researchers. This prevents getting the cells from an embryo. Embryonic stem cells come from eggs fertilized at an in-vitro clinic. These embryos are either no longer needed or wanted. There must be an informed consent received to use the embryo. A common misconception is that these are derived from an embryo fertilized inside a woman’s body. This is not true and would be unethical if a doctor retrieved the cells in this manner. Embryonic cells have a higher potential to repair or regenerate tissues and organs......

Words: 1037 - Pages: 5

Controversies of Stem Cell Research

...ABSTRACT Stem cells have offered much hope by promising to greatly extend the numbers and range of patients who could benefit from transplants, and to provide cell replacement therapy to treat debilitating diseases such as diabetes, Parkinson's and Huntington's disease. The issue of stem cell research is politically charged, prompting biologists to begin engaging in ethical debates, Stem cell research offers great promise for understanding basic mechanisms of human development and differentiation, as well as the hope for new treatments. However, human stem cell research also raises sharp ethical and political controversies. This paper will discuss the types of stem cells as well as some of the controversies involved in stem cell research. Introduction According to Wikipedia, stem cell can be defined as “biological cells found in all multicellular organisms, that can divide (through mitosis) and differentiate into diverse specialized cell types and can self-renew to produce more stem cells.” A stem cell could be regarded as one of the basic building blocks of the human body. Stem cells are important because they have the ability to become different cell types, and scientists are working on developing ways to use stem cells to repair or regenerate damaged organs or tissues. This could lead to therapies for a whole range of conditions such as heart disease, diabetes, Parkinson's disease or Alzheimer's, although at present it is impossible to tell whether this will......

Words: 1712 - Pages: 7

Stem Cell Research

...Death: Stem Cells and People Stem cell research, a growing study among scientists and research, has reached new heights and controversy. In 1998, Dr. James Thomson’s scientific breakthrough of a technique to isolate and grow human embryonic stem cells “offered great promise for new ways of treating disease” (AAA). Many researchers and scientists hope to study the stem cells to understand the process of our cells and the cell development and to correct the problems of cells that create defects in human beings. However, there are certain opponents against such research. They believe that is unethical and morally wrong because the embryonic cells are destroying human life and there are other alternatives to embryonic stem cells such as adult cells and cord cells. Is stem cell research ethical? Yes, stem cell research is ethical and can be used to cure any type of disease or injury. Before divulging into stem cell research, one must understand the types of stem cells and where they come from. According to The National Institutes of Health (NIH) website, stem cells are unspecialized cells that are able to “develop into many different many cell types in the body during early life and growth”…and are “capable of renewing themselves through cell division”. With this mind, the cells could form into any type, helping to repair and replace such cells. While it seems fascinating that these cells can repair certain parts of the human organs, there are only three sources of stems cells......

Words: 805 - Pages: 4

Human Embryonic Stem Cells

...Introduction Human embryonic stem cells (hES cells) are currently discussed not only by the biologists by whom they were discovered but also by the medical profession, media, ethicists, governments and politicians. There are several reasons for this. On the one hand, these ‘super cells’ have a major clinical potential in tissue repair, with their proponents believing that they represent the future relief or cure of a wide range of common disabilities; replacement of defective cells in a patient by transplantation of hES cell‐derived equivalents would restore normal function. On the other hand, the use of hES cells is highly controversial because they are derived from human pre‐implantation embryos. To date, most embryos used for the establishment of hES cell lines have been spare embryos from IVF, but the creation of embryos specifically for deriving hES cells is also under discussion. The most controversial variant of this is the transfer of a somatic cell‐nucleus from a patient to an enucleated oocyte (unfertilized egg) in order to produce hES cells genetically identical to that patient for ‘autologous’ transplantation (so‐called ‘therapeutic’ cloning); this may prevent tissue rejection. The question ‘Can these cells be isolated and used and, if so, under what conditions and restrictions’ is presently high on the political and ethical agenda, with policies and legislation being formulated in many countries to regulate their derivation. The UK has been the first to......

Words: 8387 - Pages: 34

Embryonic Stem Cell Research: the Next Best Thing

...Embryonic Stem Cell Research: The Next Best Thing Have you ever gone to the doctor when you are not feeling well? The doctor probably gave you some good advice and maybe a pill and you felt better in about a week. This happens every day all over the country every day. But what happens when good advice and a pill will not help this time? A diagnosis of organ failure, spinal cord injury, and diabetes, Parkinson’s disease or Huntington’s disease is life altering. After the shock wears off you might start researching different therapies and come across something called stem cell research. Stem cell research has been around since the 1970’s but has gotten a lot of attention in the last several years. It has even risen to the level of Presidential campaigns: Senator John Kerry (D) made embryonic stem cell research a major theme in his 2004 run for President. The controversial issue comes in when the discussion turns toward embryonic stem cell versus adult stem cells. Stem cells are undifferentiated cells found throughout the body in tissue and organs. Undifferentiated cell are cells that have not specialized. They are there to repair and maintain the tissue or organ where they are found. Stem cells are also found in in the cord blood in the umbilical cord of newborns. The last place is embryonic stem cells. Embryonic stem cells are very special because they are pluripotent; they are capable of becoming any cell in the body as opposed to an adult stem cell that is......

Words: 1246 - Pages: 5

Is Embryonic Stem Cell Research Ethical?

...Is Embryonic Stem Cell Research Ethical? The introduction and expansion of embryonic stem cell research initiated a highly debated ethical topic. Can our society agree to disagree? What are embryonic stem cells? What are stem cells? Is all stem cell research considered abortion? Debates surrounding embryonic stem cell research is further complicated by social standards and needs, religious beliefs, and personal morals. In November of 1998, a group of researchers announced that they had successfully isolated and grown a special kind of cell with the potential to develop into virtually any kind of human tissue. The scientists had made the discovery of embryonic stem cells. The discovery was considered to be an innovative experience with immeasurable capabilities in the field of biological research. The research experts and scientific community believed the new discovery could lead to new methods of drug development, improve understanding of biology, and aid in the advancement of tissue and organ transplantation. They realized that there would be legal, ethical, political, and technical obstacles to overcome, but they never envisioned the “sleeping giant” that was woken due to this historic discovery in science. Stem cells are classified into two main types: embryonic stem cells and adults stem cells. Embryonic stem cells come from embryos that have developed from eggs that have been fertilized by male sperm or in a petri dish in a lab by artificial......

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Stem Cell Research

...Can We Afford to Not Explore Stem Cell Research? An Argument in Support Stem Cell Research John P. Bailey English Composition, ENG101V2A Professor Rosenberg August 8, 2011 Abstract In recent years, a battle has resurrected between fundamentalist conservatives and science and medicine. Fundamentalist-minded religious factions have made a hard line stance that embryonic stem cell research is destructive towards life. Stem cells can be derived from the destruction of human embryos. Fertility clinics, the largest provider of stem cells, supply for research embryonic cells and in-vitro-fertilized embryos. The scientific world has asserted that embryonic stem cells have a regenerative nature and possess the potential to repair almost every type of damaged tissue. In terms of medical advancement, the future benefits of stem cells are tremendous. While examining the sources of these embryonic stem cells and their alternative disposal, I will assert that ignoring embryonic stem cell research is tantamount to neglectful suffering and death. The possibilities of the associated medical advancements are enormous. Can We Afford to Not Explore Stem Cell Research? An Argument in Support Embryonic Stem Cell Research Embryonic stem cells are in the vanguard of research with the greatest potential in the biomedical world of today. Stem cells have unheard of qualities that strike the medical field......

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Stem Cell Research

...Stem Cells For as long as humans exist optimal health will continue to remain necessary for a productive life. As new medical discoveries are made each year humans become healthier, and their life expectancy increases. Stem cell research, a relatively new field, aims to improve and lengthen human life. The possibility that stem cells could cure many long term health problems makes this research beneficial to the human race. The value of stem cells comes from their ability to replicate many times and develop into tissue. Scientists suggest that stem cells have the ability to treat debilitating health problems such as: Alzheimer’s disease, spinal cord injuries, strokes, burns, heart disease, diabetes, osteoarthritis, and rheumatoid arthritis. Scientists obtain stem cells from embryos, adult tissue, umbilical cord blood, and bioengineered cells. The major controversy surrounding stem cell research and therapies is due to the fact that embryos are destroyed when harvesting the cells. Embryonic stem cells, also called blastocysts, exist in three to five day old embryos. Destroying embryos brings up ethical concerns for many individuals. Despite this controversy scientists aspire to use embryonic stem cells because they can differentiate into every type of cells, whereas adult stem cells can be differentiated only into the cells, from where they were originated. In order to decide how one feels about stem cell research, one must first decide when life begins. Does life begin......

Words: 1416 - Pages: 6

Stem Cell Research

...STEM CELL RESEARCH AND THERAPYAND ITS IMPACTS ON SOCIETY Abstract There are several types of stem cells being used in stem cell research and therapy today. They are embryonic, adult and induced pluripotent stem cells. Each will be discussed further. This topic has stirred much moral, ethical and political debate as whether cells from fetuses should be used in this research. This impacts governmental policies on laws and funding. Another issue that must be analyzed is the economics and who should have access to this treatment. The views of people and government on this research differ greatly across the world. There are countries that have very strict laws restricting this research while others take an extremely liberal stance. Stem Cell Research and Therapy and Its Impacts on Society Introduction Stem cells are the basic unit of life that gives rise to all living things. They are the undifferentiated cells that transform into the specialized cells that make up all of the tissues in organisms. With further research and understating, these cells can be used in medicine to cure a wide range of diseases. The most important type of stem cell to humans is the pluripotent stem cell which is usually obtained from human embryos. This has sparked controversy in many aspects of human life. In this paper, we will concentrate on animal and human stem cell research, and its impact on society. A Brief Description Of The Technology And An Explanation Of The......

Words: 6987 - Pages: 28

Stem Cell Research

... Stem Cell Research offers hope to millions of American with diseases like Diabetes, Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s. The hope has been that one day they may unlock the secret of human development and yield powerful therapies to treat a wide variety of genetic disorders and diseases, including cancer, heart disease, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and more. Catholic Church has actively encouraged stem cell research; Contrary to what some may believe, the church is not opposed to all forms of stem cell research. Catholic Church believes that the use of adult stem cells as a “better way” to achieve the therapeutic promise of stem cells. Only research using embryotic stem cells have been condemned by the Church. The stem cell debate is filled with controversy question and confusion about science, cures and how we should treat human life at every stage. So what is a stem cell, it is an undifferentiated cell of a multicellular organism that is capable of giving rise to indefinitely more cells of the same type, and from which certain other kinds of cells arise by differentiation. Or some people see stem cells are undifferentiated cells that serve the body as the universal building block and repair kit (Monitoring, 2014). They can become any of the specialized cells of the body’s various tissues and organs. They also have the capability to produce other types of specialized cells, such as brain cells, muscle cells, and lung cells just to name a few . Stem Cells come......

Words: 1066 - Pages: 5

Embryonic Stem Cells

...Harvesting Embryonic Stem Cells Harvesting embryonic stem cells can be an argumentative topic with differing opinions. I believe by researching and experimenting on embryonic stem cells, the results can be beneficial to society through medical treatments. I believe this research will benefit medical science into further advancement. The human body contains more than 220 differentiation cell types that are acquired from a collection of cells that are referred to as embryonic stem cells. Furthermore, these cells originate from an embryo, within the inner cell mass of a blastocyst that is known to be five days old. Moreover, these cells are classified to be pluripotent, which can individualize inside any three layers of the germ. Thus, embryonic stem cells are able to reform relatively any part of the human body. In addition, these cells are capable of cloning endlessly. As a result, these cells can benefit in medicine for both regenerative medicine and medical research. Regenerative therapy is the process of reconstruction or substitution of new tissue developed with the supervision of embryonic stem cells caused by obscured and impaired tissue from a disease or injury. Therefore, when the stem cells are injected into the patient’s body, those cells locate to the injured area and begin to diffuse and expand by renewing the injured cells; thus, recovering the bodily functions in that area. A few of the illnesses that can be treated through the help of embryonic stem cells......

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Stem Cell Research

...Research paper on Stem Cell Research Legislation and the related legal issues: What is the history of Stem Cell Research Legislation in the United States? How does it compare to comparable statutes in the rest of the world? In this paper talk about what the current legislative state of affairs is and where the law on stem cells in the United States should go in the future and why. Make sure you use ample research and cited sources to support your arguments but make sure to state your own opinion on the issues as well. Stem Cell Research TJ AS OF: 2/4/2009--Introduced. Stem Cell Research Improvement Act of 2009 - Amends the Public Health Service Act to require the Secretary of Health and Human Services to conduct and support research that utilizes human embryonic stem cells, regardless of the date on which the stem cells were derived from a human embryo. Limits such research to stem cells that meet the following requirements: (1) the stem cells were derived from human embryos donated from in vitro fertilization clinics, were created for the purposes of fertility treatment, and were in excess of the needs of the individuals seeking such treatment; (2) prior to donation, it was determined that the embryos would never be implanted in a woman and would otherwise be discarded; and (3) the individuals seeking fertility treatment donated the embryos with written informed consent and received no financial or other inducements. Requires the Director of the National Institutes......

Words: 3563 - Pages: 15

Embryonic Stem Cell Research

...Embryonic Stem Cell Research Almost everyone in the world knows someone who has suffered because of disease. All people whose lives have been devastated by disease have asked or hoped for a cure. What everyone should know is that a cure is possible, but some beliefs are stopping cures from being found. Embryonic stem cell research could provide solutions to medical illnesses that scientists and doctors have been searching for for years. However, certain belief systems argue that an embryo is a person, and destroying an embryo for research is murder. The essential question concerning stem cell research is summed up by this quote from President Bush, “"As I thought through this issue I kept returning to two fundamental questions," Bush stated in an address to the nation. "First, are these frozen embryos human life and therefore something precious to be protected? And second, if they're going to be destroyed anyway, shouldn't they be used for a greater good, for research that has the potential to save and improve other lives?"” (Update: Stem Cell Research). Embryonic stem cell research is a valid, ethical form of medical research that the United States should fund because it has the potential to cure many diseases, an embryo is not equivalent to a human being, the embryos used will be destroyed even without the research, and the United States will fall behind other nations in biomedical research progress. There are many medical problems that can be solved through stem......

Words: 2739 - Pages: 11

Stem Cell Research

...FALFA11 Sec E The history of Stem Cell Research Legislation in the United States Adult stem cell research on humans began in the 1960's, first achieving success in the treatment of a patient with severe combined immunodeficiency disorder in 1968. Since the early 1970's, adult stem cells have been successfully used for treatment of immunodeficiency and leukemia. Many are in support of the scope, nature, necessity and urgency of stem cell research. If the possibility is there to preserve life and cure diseases such as Cancer, Leukemia, Heart Disease AIDS/HIV, the United States Federal Government should issue more funds towards stem cell research. Those very same people that are against stem cell research may someday find themselves in dire need stem cells to save their lives. A German AIDS patient was able to stop drugs he had been taking for 10 years after getting a transplant of stem cells from a donor with a rare gene variant known to resist the deadly disease. The transplant also cured his leukemia, researchers reported. Embryonic stem cell research does not appear to be ethical and it seems as if a life is being taken in the process. One can’t help but pose the question, “when do the actual stages of life begin”? A Blastocyst is a thin-walled hollow structure in early embryonic development that contains a cluster of cells called the inner cell mass from which the embryo arises. The outer layer of cells gives rise to the placenta and other supporting tissues needed......

Words: 1470 - Pages: 6

Embryonic Stem Cell Research and Christianity

...Embryonic Stem Cell Research In 1998, the world was introduced to the start of embryonic stem cell research. It has since been the topic of a heated debate between politicians, religious figures, ethicists, theologians and scientists. It raises the question of whether or not the ends justify the means. Many people seem to have a different answer to this question but the overall response from a Catholic position, from an individual and Catholic Church standpoint is loud and clear: embryonic stem cell research is immoral. The sanctity of life is held in high regard in the Catholic tradition, therefore making embryonic stem cell research morally wrong. To justify this, it is important to consider whether or not an embryo is a human from perspectives that are for and against this research, and their justifications. Whilst there is no united Catholic view, drawing from traditional ethics and Catholic principles can give an estimate of the overall Catholic perspective on the treatment of human embryos as opposed to the foreseen medical benefits on the other end of the spectrum. In a broad sense, the use of human embryos is unjustifiable and wrong in the eyes of the Catholic community, no matter how promising the benefits are as it involves the killing of an embryo, and thus by extension, can be regarded as murder. “We value the preciousness of life…as far as IVF embryos are concerned, those who have the responsibility make those decisions, have already made an important ethical......

Words: 2225 - Pages: 9

Preacher | IMDb: 7 HD Whitney | 0 rponse